Elmira has been one of the tougher ECAC West teams that not only win in the ECAC West, but play a tough schedule home and away, no doubt.
However, they've also had 18 NCAA appearances with 0 NCAA Phinal Phore wins and just 6 NCAA Quarter Final wins TOTAL combined. A mere .28% when you take out Neumann.**
I don't think anyone has ever claimed the ECAC West to be garbage. You can take Plattsburgh, Oswego, Norwich, and SNC and put them in the ECAC West and they would be 1-3 every year. Im not sure you could put the ECAC West teams in the old NCHA or even SUNYAC and they would be the Conference champs like "some" (and by some I mean a very few) think every year. For one thing, Utica would actually have to play these "crap" SUNYAC teams on the road for a change, which they are just a .500 team against the SUNYAC on the road, go figure. There is no argument that the lower half of the SUNYAC is below that of the ECAC West bottom half. But I still think the upper half (Oswego, Plattsburgh, Geneseo, and Buff State) are just as comparable to Utica, Hobart, Neumann, and Elmira. The ECAC West is not made up of a bunch of Brockports, Morrisville, and Cortlands (Utica says thank you), but they are not made up of a bunch of Oswego, Norwich, SNC's and Plattsburgh's either. I've proven how the almighty SOS is flawed, I've proven how their record in the NCAA's is well below average, and I've proven (as well as others) that Utica (despite the inflated SOS) STILL does not have the best SOS. Case closed.