Women's DIII 2009-2010 Fan Opinion Poll

[4and20]

Re: Women's DIII 2009-2010 Fan Opinion Poll

I've decided that Adrian needs to host an 8 team tournament next year over winter break:
Adrian
Gustavus
Superior
River Falls
Plattsburh
Elmira
RIT
Middlebury/Amherst

No point even wasting anytime inviting Middlebury they would never travel that far. I mean come on a bus from the Detroit airport allllll the way to Adrian, what's that 59 miles, Google say's it would take almost two hours. Man that is almost as far as from the Minnepolis Airport to St. Peter, MN.

 

[hockeyfan1]

Re: Women's DIII 2009-2010 Fan Opinion Poll

No point even wasting anytime inviting Middlebury they would never travel that far. I mean come on a bus from the Detroit airport allllll the way to Adrian, what's that 59 miles, Google say's it would take almost two hours. Man that is almost as far as from the Minnepolis Airport to St. Peter, MN.

NICE

 

[nbound]

Re: Women's DIII 2009-2010 Fan Opinion Poll

Upon Further Deep Intense Review the Berry Patch has come up with 4 different polls witch you may or may not like As of 1/26/10

The top ten by pts in games played against opponents who were @ .500 or better at the time of the game

1 Platts 21 pts 10-1-1
2 Trinity 19 pts 9-1-1
3 Amherst 15 pts 6-1-1
4 elmira 13 pts 6--4-1
5 UWRF 12 pts 5-2-2
6 GAC 12 pts 5-2-2
7 St Olaf 12 pts 6-5-0
8 UWSP 11 pts 5-3-1
9 Middlebury 11 pts 5-4-1
10 St Mary 11 pts 5-4-1
11 UWS 11 pts 5-5-1


The top ten by % of games won against opponents @ .500 or better at time of games played

1 Platt .873 10-1-1
2 Trinity .818 9-1-1
3 St Kate .666 4-2-0
4 Amherst .600 6-1-3
5 Utica .571 4-2-1
6 mville .571 4-3-0
7 UWRF .555 5-2-2
8 GAC .555 5-2-2
9 UWSP .555 5-3-1
10 St Olaf .545 6-5-0


Poll #3 overall W/L based on #of wins

1 Trinnity 14-1-2
2 Platt 13-1-1
3 Lake Foirest 13-2-2
4 Holy Cross 13-3-1
5 Elmira 13-4-1
6 Amherst 11-1-4
7 Norwich 11-3-3
8 Mville 11-4-1
9 Umass 11-7-0
10 St Kate 10-3-1


and finally poll #4 based on overall winning %

1 Platt .900
2 Lake Forest .824
3 Trinity .822
4 Amherst .812
5 Holy Cross .794
6 st Kate .769
7 Elmira .750
8 Norwich .735
9 UWRF .719
10 MVille .719

A little something for everyone I hope

 

[videohockey]

Re: Women's DIII 2009-2010 Fan Opinion Poll

Upon Further Deep Intense Review the Berry Patch has come up with 4 different polls witch you may or may not like As of 1/26/10

The top ten by pts in games played against opponents who were @ .500 or better at the time of the game

1 Platts 21 pts 10-1-1
2 Trinity 19 pts 9-1-1
3 Amherst 15 pts 6-1-1
4 elmira 13 pts 6--4-1
5 UWRF 12 pts 5-2-2
6 GAC 12 pts 5-2-2
7 St Olaf 12 pts 6-5-0
8 UWSP 11 pts 5-3-1
9 Middlebury 11 pts 5-4-1
10 St Mary 11 pts 5-4-1
11 UWS 11 pts 5-5-1


The top ten by % of games won against opponents @ .500 or better at time of games played

1 Platt .873 10-1-1
2 Trinity .818 9-1-1
3 St Kate .666 4-2-0
4 Amherst .600 6-1-3
5 Utica .571 4-2-1
6 mville .571 4-3-0
7 UWRF .555 5-2-2
8 GAC .555 5-2-2
9 UWSP .555 5-3-1
10 St Olaf .545 6-5-0


Poll #3 overall W/L based on #of wins

1 Trinnity 14-1-2
2 Platt 13-1-1
3 Lake Foirest 13-2-2
4 Holy Cross 13-3-1
5 Elmira 13-4-1
6 Amherst 11-1-4
7 Norwich 11-3-3
8 Mville 11-4-1
9 Umass 11-7-0
10 St Kate 10-3-1


and finally poll #4 based on overall winning %

1 Platt .900
2 Lake Forest .824
3 Trinity .822
4 Amherst .812
5 Holy Cross .794
6 st Kate .769
7 Elmira .750
8 Norwich .735
9 UWRF .719
10 MVille .719

A little something for everyone I hope

I can accept all four!

 

[PrezdeJohnson09]

Re: Women's DIII 2009-2010 Fan Opinion Poll

Upon Further Deep Intense Review the Berry Patch has come up with 4 different polls witch you may or may not like As of 1/26/10

The top ten by pts in games played against opponents who were @ .500 or better at the time of the game

1 Platts 21 pts 10-1-1
2 Trinity 19 pts 9-1-1
3 Amherst 15 pts 6-1-1
4 elmira 13 pts 6--4-1
5 UWRF 12 pts 5-2-2
6 GAC 12 pts 5-2-2
7 St Olaf 12 pts 6-5-0
8 UWSP 11 pts 5-3-1
9 Middlebury 11 pts 5-4-1
10 St Mary 11 pts 5-4-1
11 UWS 11 pts 5-5-1


The top ten by % of games won against opponents @ .500 or better at time of games played

1 Platt .873 10-1-1
2 Trinity .818 9-1-1
3 St Kate .666 4-2-0
4 Amherst .600 6-1-3
5 Utica .571 4-2-1
6 mville .571 4-3-0
7 UWRF .555 5-2-2
8 GAC .555 5-2-2
9 UWSP .555 5-3-1
10 St Olaf .545 6-5-0


Poll #3 overall W/L based on #of wins

1 Trinnity 14-1-2
2 Platt 13-1-1
3 Lake Foirest 13-2-2
4 Holy Cross 13-3-1
5 Elmira 13-4-1
6 Amherst 11-1-4
7 Norwich 11-3-3
8 Mville 11-4-1
9 Umass 11-7-0
10 St Kate 10-3-1


and finally poll #4 based on overall winning %

1 Platt .900
2 Lake Forest .824
3 Trinity .822
4 Amherst .812
5 Holy Cross .794
6 st Kate .769
7 Elmira .750
8 Norwich .735
9 UWRF .719
10 MVille .719

A little something for everyone I hope

Should take the average of those four polls to come up with the real one

 

[Plugger]

Re: Women's DIII 2009-2010 Fan Opinion Poll

Upon Further Deep Intense Review the Berry Patch has come up with 4 different polls witch you may or may not like As of 1/26/10

The top ten by pts in games played against opponents who were @ .500 or better at the time of the game

1 Platts 21 pts 10-1-1
2 Trinity 19 pts 9-1-1
3 Amherst 15 pts 6-1-1
4 elmira 13 pts 6--4-1
5 UWRF 12 pts 5-2-2
6 GAC 12 pts 5-2-2
7 St Olaf 12 pts 6-5-0
8 UWSP 11 pts 5-3-1
9 Middlebury 11 pts 5-4-1
10 St Mary 11 pts 5-4-1
11 UWS 11 pts 5-5-1


The top ten by % of games won against opponents @ .500 or better at time of games played

1 Platt .873 10-1-1
2 Trinity .818 9-1-1
3 St Kate .666 4-2-0
4 Amherst .600 6-1-3
5 Utica .571 4-2-1
6 mville .571 4-3-0
7 UWRF .555 5-2-2
8 GAC .555 5-2-2
9 UWSP .555 5-3-1
10 St Olaf .545 6-5-0


Poll #3 overall W/L based on #of wins

1 Trinnity 14-1-2
2 Platt 13-1-1
3 Lake Foirest 13-2-2
4 Holy Cross 13-3-1
5 Elmira 13-4-1
6 Amherst 11-1-4
7 Norwich 11-3-3
8 Mville 11-4-1
9 Umass 11-7-0
10 St Kate 10-3-1


and finally poll #4 based on overall winning %

1 Platt .900
2 Lake Forest .824
3 Trinity .822
4 Amherst .812
5 Holy Cross .794
6 st Kate .769
7 Elmira .750
8 Norwich .735
9 UWRF .719
10 MVille .719

A little something for everyone I hope

Wow....very impressive, but you have way too much free time!!

Holy Cross.....I thought you were not going to count them?? Have you changed your mind??

 

[nbound]

Re: Women's DIII 2009-2010 Fan Opinion Poll

Wow....very impressive, but you have way too much free time!!

Holy Cross.....I thought you were not going to count them?? Have you changed your mind??

Thats what retirement does for you
Holy Crossand any non D3 team) if one is to consider wins and losses against those non D3 teams above .500 in factoring how other teams do against them, why not show where they would be in any polls if they qualified.
The official Berry Patch poll ( the one that gets turned in will not include them in standings being that most people do not include them. I will mention them as a side note if they qualify)

 

[powerplay17]

Re: Women's DIII 2009-2010 Fan Opinion Poll

1.Plattsburgh-Record speaks for itself
2.Amherst-Minor blemish w Colby
3.Elmira-Still scary
4.Mville-Did something teams below couldn't do.Beat Elmira
5.Middlebury- Win vs Trinity gets them back on track
6.Trinity-Bad weekend,Creates doubt
7.RIT- Not sure why there so high 0 wins against teams above them
8.Lake Forest-Best of the west,I think
9.Gustavus-Reputation helps them in this poll
10.Norwich-Good record up and coming program

 

[hdbub59]

Re: Women's DIII 2009-2010 Fan Opinion Poll

1.Plattsburgh-Record speaks for itself
2.Amherst-Minor blemish w Colby
3.Elmira-Still scary
4.Mville-Did something teams below couldn't do.Beat Elmira
5.Middlebury- Win vs Trinity gets them back on track
6.Trinity-Bad weekend,Creates doubt
7.RIT- Not sure why there so high 0 wins against teams above them
8.Lake Forest-Best of the west,I think
9.Gustavus-Reputation helps them in this poll
10.Norwich-Good record up and coming program

Pretty good, I agree.

 

[Plugger]

Re: Women's DIII 2009-2010 Fan Opinion Poll

1) Plattsburgh
2) Amherst
3) Elmira
4) Middlebury
5) River Falls
6) RIT
7) Trinity
8) Lake Forest
9) Manhattanville
10) Gustavus

 

[gojackets]

Re: Women's DIII 2009-2010 Fan Opinion Poll

Boy...I just don't know...except #1

1. Plattsburgh
2. Amherst
3. Elmira
4. Lake Forest
5. River Falls
6. Gustavus
7. St. Kate
8. Trinity
9. RIT
10. Manhattanville

 

[LadyFalconsFan]

Re: Women's DIII 2009-2010 Fan Opinion Poll

Ok. Not just cause I'm an RF fan, but because I know the quality of the teams Lake Forest has played... They haven't had a tough year. I am impressed with their outcome this weekend, but still not convinced that they deserve a ranking.

 

[gojackets]

Re: Women's DIII 2009-2010 Fan Opinion Poll

1.Plattsburgh-Record speaks for itself
2.Amherst-Minor blemish w Colby
3.Elmira-Still scary
4.Mville-Did something teams below couldn't do.Beat Elmira
5.Middlebury- Win vs Trinity gets them back on track
6.Trinity-Bad weekend,Creates doubt
7.RIT- Not sure why there so high 0 wins against teams above them
8.Lake Forest-Best of the west,I think
9.Gustavus-Reputation helps them in this poll
10.Norwich-Good record up and coming program

theres just no way that Mville an Norwich can both be in the top ten with the schedules they play. I don't think 1 win over Trinity is enough to bring Middlebury back in. I definitely think this weekend opened the door that only one Nescac team will be in the NCAA's.

 

[gojackets]

Re: Women's DIII 2009-2010 Fan Opinion Poll

Ok. Not just cause I'm an RF fan, but because I know the quality of the teams Lake Forest has played... They haven't had a tough year. I am impressed with their outcome this weekend, but still not convinced that they deserve a ranking.

And when they sweep falls???

 

[Plugger]

Re: Women's DIII 2009-2010 Fan Opinion Poll

theres just no way that Mville an Norwich can both be in the top ten with the schedules they play. I don't think 1 win over Trinity is enough to bring Middlebury back in. I definitely think this weekend opened the door that only one Nescac team will be in the NCAA's.

Not sure if I agree with your comments, but this is a fan's opinion poll and you have as much right to base your comments and bias as other people who like Manhattanville and Norwich in top 10. Also, as Obserbear points out (despite your dislike of Middlebury) they could host NESCAC's this year, as they now control their destiny, if they win their next 4 NESCAC games. Does not mean they will win NESCAC, and get automatic bid, but they seem to be getting more out of their freshman.

 

[Phil D. Stands]

Re: Women's DIII 2009-2010 Fan Opinion Poll

1) Plattsburgh
2) Amherst
3) Elmira
4) Middlebury
5) Lake Forest
6) Adrian
7) Trinity
8) RIT
9) Manhattanville
10) St.Kate's

 

[LadyFalconsFan]

Re: Women's DIII 2009-2010 Fan Opinion Poll

And when they sweep falls???

IF they can do that, then i'll agree. but until then no.

 

[gojackets]

Re: Women's DIII 2009-2010 Fan Opinion Poll

Not sure if I agree with your comments, but this is a fan's opinion poll and you have as much right to base your comments and bias as other people who like Manhattanville and Norwich in top 10. Also, as Obserbear points out (despite your dislike of Middlebury) they could host NESCAC's this year, as they now control their destiny, if they win their next 4 NESCAC games. Does not mean they will win NESCAC, and get automatic bid, but they seem to be getting more out of their freshman.

I don't think that being the NESCAC champ is anything to write home about this year..look at their record out of conference. I really don't forsee more than 1 team coming out of the NESCAC for the NCAA's. IF trinity had won both games this weekend and their remaining games, and lost in the NESCAC finals it would have been difficult to keep them out, however now..I don't believe so

 

[nbound]

Re: Women's DIII 2009-2010 Fan Opinion Poll

Ok. Not just cause I'm an RF fan, but because I know the quality of the teams Lake Forest has played... They haven't had a tough year. I am impressed with their outcome this weekend, but still not convinced that they deserve a ranking.

Being that Adrian is the only team thus far in the NCHA that has beaten Lake Forest, I would say that speaks volumes. Adrian is the only top team I have not yet seen. Watching UWRF, UWS,and UWSP is like seeing identical triplets. Sometimes they look good other times they look pretty ordinary. I hardly would consider UWRF the gold standard by which Lake Forest should be judged by. UWS couldn't beat them,UWSP couldn't beat them and UWEC could not beat them. 15-2-2 looks pretty good to me as of now. By all means good luck to UWRF when they face Lake Forest.

 

[pucko]

Re: Women's DIII 2009-2010 Fan Opinion Poll

Ok. Not just cause I'm an RF fan, but because I know the quality of the teams Lake Forest has played... They haven't had a tough year. I am impressed with their outcome this weekend, but still not convinced that they deserve a ranking.

They beat and tied UWSP....so did River Falls. They beat and tied UWS....RF split with them. They swept UWEC.....RF tied them twice. Both of them split with Adrian. I think the only "harder" team in the schedule that Falls has played is Gustavus and they just split with St. Kate's....So how is that the RF should always be ranked but LF doesn't deserve a ranking when they've fared better team per team?