Re: The end of leagues as we know?
Just a few points.
Miami pushed hard for this --- Its in one of the newspaper articles. Miami's attendance in a decimated CCHA would of taken a massive hit to a program that just shelled out $40+ million for a new arena. This was a no-brainer for them.
Agreed, Miami and whoever else leave from the CCHA have the most to gain from this. But again, it is highly debatable whether simply joining the existing WCHA wouldn't be just as good if not better for MU.
And also, again, Miami's rink holds 3,600. Increased ticket sales are capped at a pretty low level of financial significance.
UNO was drawing 8,000 towards the end of last season. Their fans have proven that they'll back a winner and they want to see name brand opponents. Omaha is a wealthy city and there's no reason that they won't draw the second biggest crowds in the Super League in due time. Most important, Omaha is in the heart of USHL country. Super League teams will be using Omaha trips as de facto recruiting visits.
I don't see how any of this spurs them to want to leave the WCHA. Their fans have proven they will back a winner, but will they back a team that routinely finishes 5th or 6th in an 8 team conference and is outside the NCAA bubble? Is there any reason that UNO wouldn't draw the 2nd biggest crowds in the WCHA? As far as recruiting trips, again I don't see how this is an issue exclusive to joining a start-up conference.
CC - Fanbase are not alums or people tied to the school. CC had had to drop ticket prices despite successful seasons lately because the WCHA had become too watered down. Give Springs residents name brand opponents and a few wins and it will re-energize the program. They will see an uptick in attendance.
Same issue as UNO. A team that finishes 4th-6th most years in an 8 team conference and subsequently misses out on the NCAA tournament. How does that help to create better attendance or re-energize the program? I also find your statement that ticket prices were dropped "because the WCHA had become too watered down" to be suspect. There were a lot of factors at play there. Considering UNO would be making the jump to this new conference with CC, you are basically saying ticket prices were dropped because BSU joined the league. That is a stretch to say the least.
UMD - awesome new arena & NC Banner. Say no more.
Say no more? Say anything? How do either of those things make Duluth want to leave a league filled with natural rivals, low travel costs, and the chance to be a big dog with regular trips to the NCAA for a league where the will be middle of the pack and struggle greatly to get on the right side of the pairwise?
DU & UND - Want to be national powers with NHL draftees.
Indeed. This is the only real reason this league is being pushed. DU and UND are afraid they can't stay relevant in the WCHA without Minnesota and Wisconsin in the league. I find that fear to be unrealistic.