Not sure why I am engaging in this discussion because it certainly never ends well and is somewhat pointless because it is out of our hands, but a few thoughts. I thought rpi82's comment about where the program was at the time of the extension is accurate. First 2 Smith years were poor but pre-transfer portal and hard to overhaul a roster. 19-20 a success, and I think 80% of us were content with 21-22 after the mess that was COVID. Seemed like given the circumstances they were battling pretty hard and seeing the mess the student-athletes endured, I would say that not extending the Coach would have been a pretty quick way to send the roster all the way back to square one and eliminate anything that was built the prior 5 years. FWIW, they played like 45 games that year, the whole 20 loss thing doesn't apply much to that season.
However, I do align with Engineers comment that 5 yrs was too aggressive. 3 was much wiser given the unknowns, and we are paying the debts of that now. I suspect that finances are a bigger problem than any of us on this board acknowledge. I do not feel like giving a million examples for that take, but read the writing on the wall. Shirley ****ed off all the alums and also hated athletics and the dept was severely underfunded. Look at how hard they promoted giving day this year, it seems Bowers and co are trying to fix some of the damage that was done. At the end of the day, a small upstate NY school with 2 D1 programs does not have the budget to compete with the giants, especially when they were poorly run. This trickles down into a bit of everything (coaching decisions, facilities, etc). The school needs to get the $$ figured out and treat this program as seriously as they should if they want to revive it.
Finally, to put it on the record, I think the worst-case scenario this season is a 15ish win season and 7th or so in the league and thus extending this regime. I think for long-term momentum, we either need a change or a season of significant progress (top 5 in league and LP). As always, I will be rooting hard for the Engineers. Wishing you guys a good summer and excited for some hockey coming up soon
CM- Spot on nailing it. Time passes quickly and many of us actually have to think about how long it really has been since we have been a program that produced a contender in the ECAC on a yearly basis. My last trip to Lake Placid for a tournament was just about 23 years ago. And we were never able to see our team down in Atlantic City at all during the years the tournament was held there. And we have a home less than 45 minutes away from each site! We can go over all the reasons we want for the travesty that is the last 2 decades but you have it absolutely correct, It has to be now or never. This season has to be a major turning point, not just a small blip of improvement. We still root fervently for our teams and take pride in what football, lacrosse and soccer have done during the past several years but hockey is and has been our sport. As the only Division I sport it should be our shining star. We look forward as we always do to the upcoming season but more so than ever before, is really does seem like it is now or never for the program. Go RED! And great appreciation to all of those on here who have stuck with RPI hockey for all these years of mostly disappintment.