Even though I only sorta peruse this thread once in a while, since I'm a console generation behind (PS2), I read everyone's posts for a page or so, and long for the days of a one-button/one joystick video game.
Stuff like GTA/Red Dead Rock/whatever look fun and all.....until I play them. Video games are not supposed to require knowing how each of the 15 buttons and 2 joysticks work to play. It's just too much work to be fun. Even in the sports games.....
For example, I looked at the manual to figure out how to fight in NHL2K8 this past weekend, took note of all the other "moves" you can do in regular play.....JFC.
Gimme shoot, pass, check. Maybe drop pass. Definitely one-timer. That's about it. That's all I need. Auto line change? Fine. Some auto game strategies (adjust how aggressive you are: trap, all out willy nilly)? Fine.
I tell ya, you need a friggin' doctorate to play half the games now, without failing at them within 30 seconds or being bored within 2 minutes because you can't do anything.