What's new
By:
USCHO Fan Forum

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

  • The USCHO Fan Forum has migrated to a new plaform, xenForo. Most of the function of the forum should work in familiar ways. Please note that you can switch between light and dark modes by clicking on the gear icon in the upper right of the main menu bar. We are hoping that this new platform will prove to be faster and more reliable. Please feel free to explore its features.

D-III Scores and Highlights: The stretch run and the road to the 'chip

Re: D-III Scores and Highlights: The stretch run and the road to the 'chip

twowayplay said:
Not really. Norwich does not stack up to RF or Platty in the NCAA criteria
Click to expand...

This isn't complete true.

Norwich vs. Plattsburgh
WIN % 0.8043 1 0.7963 0
SOS 0.5175 0 0.5688 1
H2H 1- 1- 0 1- 1- 0
COP 4- 2- 1 1 4- 3- 3 0
RNK 5-4-0 (.556) 6-4-3 (.577)

They tie 2-2. Norwich takes win percentage and common opponents, while Plattsburgh takes record vs ranked teams and strength of schedule.

IMHO, the large difference in SOS is Plattsburgh's biggest asset.
 
Last edited:
SeymoreHockey said:
Just looked at the boxscore of the Platty/RIT game. Looks like quite a goon show. Not the number of penalties, but the type of calls and the timing of them.
Surprized the NCAA would assign a woman to ref a playoff game. They just dont have the skills yet. (Sorry, but it's true.)
Click to expand...

I beg to differ. The women that now ref usually played womens hockey, thus knowing the rules better than the male refs. If you look at the RF/adrian box score you'll see that there was, I believe, a full female reffing staff. Although there were some questionable hits and questionable penalties, they let the girls play. And on a side note, talking to some friends that ref, I do believe the "#1" ref in the country is a female
 
Re: D-III Scores and Highlights: The stretch run and the road to the 'chip

LadyFalconsFan said:
I beg to differ. The women that now ref usually played womens hockey, thus knowing the rules better than the male refs. If you look at the RF/adrian box score you'll see that there was, I believe, a full female reffing staff. Although there were some questionable hits and questionable penalties, they let the girls play. And on a side note, talking to some friends that ref, I do believe the "#1" ref in the country is a female
Click to expand...

Sorry to disagree, but I have NEVER seen a game reffed by a woman that was "clean" and without controversy. During my Ds four years in the NCAA I also NEVER saw a female ref in the playoffs and very rarely in league games...and it was a pleasure after watching and suffering through years of agony in the PWHL!! :)
 
Re: D-III Scores and Highlights: The stretch run and the road to the 'chip

SeymoreHockey said:
Sorry to disagree, but I have NEVER seen a game reffed by a woman that was "clean" and without controversy. During my Ds four years in the NCAA I also NEVER saw a female ref in the playoffs and very rarely in league games...and it was a pleasure after watching and suffering through years of agony in the PWHL!! :)
Click to expand...

Hole Smokes. You can't be serious. !!!. What would your D say about these comments.!!!???
 
SeymoreHockey said:
Sorry to disagree, but I have NEVER seen a game reffed by a woman that was "clean" and without controversy. During my Ds four years in the NCAA I also NEVER saw a female ref in the playoffs and very rarely in league games...and it was a pleasure after watching and suffering through years of agony in the PWHL!! :)
Click to expand...

I'm yet to see a cleanly reffed game. Doesn't matter if its a male or female ref. Point is that you're doggin on women in a womens hockey forum. Smooth
 
Re: D-III Scores and Highlights: The stretch run and the road to the 'chip

OnMAA said:
Hole Smokes. You can't be serious. !!!. What would your D say about these comments.!!!???
Click to expand...

Are you kidding me?? First I had to watch the games, then I had to listen to my D ALL THE WAY HOME !!! The girls know good reffing from bad. And you know as well as me about the quality of reffing in the PW.
 
Re: D-III Scores and Highlights: The stretch run and the road to the 'chip

SeymoreHockey said:
Just looked at the boxscore of the Platty/RIT game. Looks like quite a goon show. Not the number of penalties, but the type of calls and the timing of them.
Surprized the NCAA would assign a woman to ref a playoff game. They just dont have the skills yet. (Sorry, but it's true.)
Click to expand...

Hey Archie...say Hi to "The Dingbat" and "Meathead" for us...

:rolleyes:
 
Re: D-III Scores and Highlights: The stretch run and the road to the 'chip

spwood said:
RIT wins on 2 PP goals in the third........hhhmmmmmmmmmm... that will really suck if Plattsburgh's season ends on this note....

Sorry...a fan's knee-jerk reaction to how the third period went...
Click to expand...

I'm not going to say the reffing was good, but the last penalty was legit. Shaubel punched her in the head.
 
Re: D-III Scores and Highlights: The stretch run and the road to the 'chip

I find it funny that we are blaming the loss not on the refs, but the one female ref...especially when you are used to St Louis over in Platty.

the woman ref after a quick scan is a D1 ECAC ref as she has reffed for cornell, princeton etc...I'm sure she knows what she is doing

Seymore you seem like a classy person but to blame a loss on a woman ref seems a little low class
 
Re: D-III Scores and Highlights: The stretch run and the road to the 'chip

gojackets said:
I find it funny that we are blaming the loss not on the refs, but the one female ref...especially when you are used to St Louis over in Platty.

the woman ref after a quick scan is a D1 ECAC ref as she has reffed for cornell, princeton etc...I'm sure she knows what she is doing

Seymore you seem like a classy person but to blame a loss on a woman ref seems a little low class
Click to expand...

Oh Jackets...I'm not blaming the loss on the refs. RIT is a hell of a team and Plattsburgh was in tough from the get go. Full credit to them!! I was just commenting on the gamesheet and making an observation. And your reference to the St Louis combo is not without merit...they are BAD BAD BAD!! But I won't win this argument, so I won't go further. (But it did bring 54 Fighting off the golf course with a comment, so my night is made :) )
 
Re: D-III Scores and Highlights: The stretch run and the road to the 'chip

SeymoreHockey said:
Are you kidding me?? First I had to watch the games, then I had to listen to my D ALL THE WAY HOME !!! The girls know good reffing from bad. And you know as well as me about the quality of reffing in the PW.
Click to expand...

Wait a minute. You were at the game today and then drove home to So Cal ?
 
Re: D-III Scores and Highlights: The stretch run and the road to the 'chip

Had a chance to see the Manhattanville/Norwich game... very physical... ref's were god awful... scoreboard operator had some sticky fingers..... clock was held for 20 seconds..... lucky it didn't cost the game for either squad.... Good Luck though to the Valiants... Would love to see a battle of the "M" colleges.... Manhattanville/Middlebury..... also would love to see Norwich get the at-large bid.. they are a battle tested team..
 
Re: D-III Scores and Highlights: The stretch run and the road to the 'chip

dogwatcher said:
yeah but RIT is a D1 program almost!
Click to expand...

This is rich..No team wore the D1 moniker this year more than the Cards.

In fairness however, I get why. Truth be known....Houle should have won COTY year here for what he tried to do for this graduating class. Full Stop.

Regardless of what happens going forward....Stick tap to all the Laura Hurd hopeful's in Bond, Moon, Fairfeild, Dijulio, Meade, Giroux, Mackrell and Buehler.

You were a gritty bunch to play against.
 
Last edited:
Re: D-III Scores and Highlights: The stretch run and the road to the 'chip

5 4 Fighting said:
This is rich..No team wore the D1 moniker this year more than the Cards.

In fairness however, I get why. Truth be known....Houle should have won COTY year here for what he tried to do for this graduating class. Full Stop.

Regardless of what happens going forward....Stick tap to all the Laura Hurd hopeful's in Bond, Moon, Fairfeild, Dijulio, Meade, Giroux, Mackrell and Buehler.

You were a gritty bunch to play against.
Click to expand...

Very decent of you Cowboy!! I agree.
 
Re: D-III Scores and Highlights: The stretch run and the road to the 'chip

OnMAA said:
Wait a minute. You were at the game today and then drove home to So Cal ?
Click to expand...

Haha..no...I was reflecting back to the good ole days of trucking the QEW and 401!! (and occasionally the 407 Ripoff Hwy.)
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top