Re: Boston University Offseason Thread 2: Moving Forward by Booting Forwards
mlive.com has posted a comprehensive assessment of Nicastro from his work at Detroit's development camp. I don't see enough games in person to offer an opinion (Webcasts are very limiting). FL, Hammer, others...do you agree with this evaluation and why?.
http://blog.mlive.com/snapshots/2010/07/red_wings_prospect_camp_assess_1.html
What I agree with:
-His wingspan, reach and pokechecking. These are all kind of intertwined, but yeah, there were definitely times last year when it looked like someone was around him and he'd just reach out and poke the puck away, or it looked the puck was out of the zone and he'd find a way to keep it in. The one exception that comes to mind here is Kreider beating him 1-on-1 in the Beanpot, but I think that was the exception not the rule. Kreider had a ton of speed and put on an NHL-caliber move. Most defensemen would've looked just as helpless as Nicastro.
-His skating. For someone his size, he can definitely move. He's obviously not as good a skater as Warsofsky or Shattenkirk, but he's also bigger than those two.
-His shot. Definitely very good. Not only is it hard, but I don't remember too many instances when he shot into someone last year. He's also good at keeping it down when there's traffic in front.
-His physicality. Yeah, he can mash.
-His inconsistency. There were definitely times last year when he would disappear or sit back a little too much. Then again, you could say the same about anyone on last year's team. And like that writer mentioned, he still has three years in college to go. I think he'll only get more consistent as time goes on.
What I don't agree with:
-His great outlet passes. I have no doubt that he has the potential to be a great outlet passer like Shattenkirk, but I didn't see too much of it last year. On the contrary, I actually remember a lot of his passes getting picked off in the neutral zone.
-His great positioning. Again, no doubts he has this ability, but I just didn't see it much. There were quite a few times last season when he'd pick a bad line and have someone beat him wide or he'd wait too long to turn around (both of which are problems Shattenkirk had as a freshman, too).
As I wrote this up, I realized how similar Nicastro is to Shattenkirk. Comparable skill sets (Shattenkirk had a little more raw talent) and comparable problems as a freshman. I don't expect Nicastro to make the jump to Second Team All-American like Shattenkirk did as a sophomore, but I wouldn't be totally shocked if he did.