What's new
USCHO Fan Forum

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

  • The USCHO Fan Forum has migrated to a new plaform, xenForo. Most of the function of the forum should work in familiar ways. Please note that you can switch between light and dark modes by clicking on the gear icon in the upper right of the main menu bar. We are hoping that this new platform will prove to be faster and more reliable. Please feel free to explore its features.

2024 Elections: One Last Chance for Democracy


Yup - a few here just don't get it:

America's political discordance: The Trump voters who want progressivism
Trump voters backed abortion, minimum wage and family leave — but don't get that Project 2025 would take it away


Perhaps out of fear of insulting their audiences, the pundits, journalists, and political consultants engaged in the lengthy post-mortem about Donald Trump's horrific victory Tuesday are avoiding the most obvious cause: ignorance. Millions of people who desperately want more progressive policies cast their ballots for a man whose agenda is exactly the opposite of what they want.

In response, many progressives blamed Democrats. Sen. Bernie Sanders, I-Vt., said Democrats "abandoned working class people," claiming that is why Harris lost. It's a tempting fiction because it allows progressives to feel a measure of control over the situation. We all would love to believe making different choices will lead to better outcomes. But Sanders knows it's not true. He himself worked closely with Biden to improve labor organizing and reduce healthcare costs. He shared Biden's disappointment that the Build Back Better plan that would have done even more was killed off by centrists who have since left the party. He knows that Democrats would have done more, if not hobbled by Republicans who control the House. And he knows that, if people were voting on policy, they would vote for Democrats. Trump, after all, will actively dismantle existing policies people like.

The problem wasn't Democratic policy or messaging. It's ignorance. As Heather "Digby" Parton wrote at Salon Wednesday, people backed Trump's "aesthetics and attitudes" but knew nothing about his policies. Before the election, Catherine Rampell and Youyou Zhou at the Washington Post polled voters about policies without revealing which candidate proposed them. Harris' were far more popular — even Trump voters generally liked her ideas more, as long as they knew they weren't hers.

When voters have factual information about the candidates, they prefer Democrats. Polls from earlier this year show that people who consume news from journalistic outlets — newspapers, network news programs, and news websites — overwhelmingly planned to vote for the Democratic candidate. Newspaper readers clocked in at 70% Democratic support, and network news viewers were 55% Democratic. News website readers were only less so because the survey didn't distinguish between legitimate sites like Salon and bunk outlets like Breitbart, but still: merely being a person who reads stuff makes you more liberal. In states where heavy ad spending helped educate voters a little more on Harris' plans, she lost less ground than in places where that money wasn't spent.
 
Last edited:
https://x.com/RadioFreeTom/status/1855065708033425451

Uncharacteristically, I'll say that Dems should stop beating up on themselves and firing volleys back and forth. (They can get back to that later.) American voters - as I've been warning for years - are changing, and becoming more like Trump. That's hard to counteract. /1


Maybe the mistake we all made was thinking America would elect a Black woman. I had a gut feeling they would not. But in any case, when elections are about feelings, fantasies, boredom, and resentment, the candidate who services those delusions has a natural advantage. /2


Democrats are understandably focused on voters who flipped because they're suffering economically. But a far larger number of voters werfe un-flippable and not poor! They're the comfortable Trumpers who think, like, Canada conspired with Michelle O to hijack voting machines. /3


When millions of people think that way, you can't agonize *too* much over losing another 3 pts during a global backlash against inflation (that no govt could have stopped and that the US handled well). Especially when you've won impt House/Senate races in all those states./4


The Democrats should definitely have a reckoning about their inability to recognize that becoming the party of the college-educated (which is what the GOP used to be) has affected their ability to message. And you're seeing some rumbles already. /5


But no Dem can change the fact that millions of ungettable GOP votes are set in stone not because of economic conditions - which were the best any candidate could have hoped for - but because even relatively affluent voters have spent years marinating in complete craziness. /6


And I'll add, again, that this is not some post-hoc rationalization based on this week. I've written about this for years, and warned about it at length in a book I wrote more than four years ago. That's really why I just couldn't be optimistic about this election. /7x
 
Yup - a few here just don't get it:

America's political discordance: The Trump voters who want progressivism
Trump voters backed abortion, minimum wage and family leave — but don't get that Project 2025 would take it away

Twas ever thus. My entire adult life has seen the liberal position of referendums win about 80% of the time while those same people vote for the people who will do the exact opposite.
 
Twas ever thus. My entire adult life has seen the liberal position of referendums win about 80% of the time while those same people vote for the people who will do the exact opposite.

We get and got the government we deserve. And this is why when you do have options in your life you do not forgo them.
 
NPR had a story about Montana and Tester losing. They interviewed a body shop owner who said he was depressed leading up to the election and is now relieved. He said he would have likely closed his shop had Harris won because “it just wouldn’t be worth fighting anymore.” He didn’t say what the Dems were doing that were so bad for his shop, guy seemed to have a lot of anger. He also said that he was glad they “put Tester in his place” because “he’s a democrat who acts like a Republican for our votes”.
 
The major problem and reason why these "lifestyles" are looked down upon is because they are full of, and the public facing people are generally, ****ing abhorrent people. The defending NASCAR champion is a guy who was suspended for a long period for using the N-word during a broadcast. It's also where "Let's Go Brandon!" came from. Indycar is not much better, any sport that allows Santino Ferrucci to be a face is no good. Small tracks run into the same problem as county fairs, they are really great if you fit in, ie you're white, you go to the same church, and you're Republican. If you are in any way "different" you will be made uncomfortable at best. Country music is the same, it can be great stuff but it's forward facing people are highly racist idiots. As much as we all love hockey, it's not much different. Hockey has a lot of terrible people involved in it, players to management.

When did Blaney use the N word and get suspended? They show him in an ad with Doc Rivers and Billie Jean King all the time. I doubt they would be associated with someone like that.
 
Why is it always incumbent on the left to reach out? Those same "suburban" low/moderate income households scorn the left's lifestyles (rap/hip hop, bicycling, art festivals, broadway musicals, book clubs, etc.) just as much. You see plenty of "let's go talk to the average joe in a rural diner" articles in the NYT, WaPo, NBC, etc., but you never see "let's go talk to the average jow at a place in urban ghetto" on Fox News, WSJ, right-wing media.

Blue collar pride can be just as toxic as any liberal elitism. It can hold people back ("that's your edumacation talkin'") just as much, if not more so, than a Manhattanite not knowing how to fish.
Democrats aren’t scared of a discussion either Average Diner-Joe/Jane. Fox News Entertainment viewers might shoot their TVs if they saw an Urban Ghetto voter on their screen, claiming it was self-defense during a home invasion.

In all seriousness, Democrats need to work harder to reach out because nobody on the side of the aisle has ever been successful at building the Liberal/Left/not racist version of Fox. They go lowbrow on much of what they report, while the people running the Democrats’ networks inevitably want to go highbrow to appeal to its base. Highbrow doesn’t create in-your-face outrage in which Fox’s and OANN’s viewers bathe.
 
You can't really reach out to people when 75% of the things they believe about politics, society, Democrats in general, and any number of other things have no basis in reality.

Half this country have built themselves a little fantasy version of the world, and they're quite content to stay there. Nothing anyone can say to them will convince them otherwise.
 
So, I post a comment hoping libs pay some mind to Bernie's post-election comment, and dxmn immediately takes issue with it. His post elicits likes from just about everyone on this board. My original post, meanwhile, elicits a like from Mr. Drew.

Either of those alone is pretty convincing evidence I'm an idiot. Together, they are irrefutable.

Just shoot me now and throw me over the fence.
 
So, I post a comment hoping libs pay some mind to Bernie's post-election comment, and dxmn immediately takes issue with it. His post elicits likes from just about everyone on this board. My original post, meanwhile, elicits a like from Mr. Drew.

Either of those alone is pretty convincing evidence I'm an idiot. Together, they are irrefutable.

Just shoot me now and throw me over the fence.

I'd love to believe Bernie Sanders is right and that if the Dems followed him they'd be in control of everything right now. Unfortunately I don't believe that. The people have spoken and the people want autocracy, xenophobia, and misogyny.

And they are happy about their choice.
 
I'd love to believe Bernie Sanders is right and that if the Dems followed him they'd be in control of everything right now. Unfortunately I don't believe that. The people have spoken and the people want autocracy, xenophobia, and misogyny.

And they are happy about their choice.

I think the vast majority of people only care about themselves and their situation. The people on this board are major outliers in a lot of ways.
 
I'd love to believe Bernie Sanders is right and that if the Dems followed him they'd be in control of everything right now. Unfortunately I don't believe that. The people have spoken and the people want autocracy, xenophobia, and misogyny.

And they are happy about their choice.

I kind of share that sentiment, but the voter motivation we care about in this discussion is not that of committed maggots, who will never change, regardless of the facts on the ground. I don’t know what we call those votes, but it’s what . . . 5-8% of the total, if that? Or is it a waste of time trying to distinguish the gettable votes from the ungettable?
 
I kind of share that sentiment, but the voter motivation we care about in this discussion is not that of committed maggots, who will never change, regardless of the facts on the ground. I don’t know what we call those votes, but it’s what . . . 5-8% of the total, if that? Or is it a waste of time trying to distinguish the gettable votes from the ungettable?

No, I don't think you get it. They're not gettable. If they would vote for Trump against any other option then there is nothing you could do to convince them otherwise. Stop thinking their gettable and start believing reality. And reality is we hate women, we hate immigrants, and we love strong men who are assholes.

This is who we are.
 
I'd love to believe Bernie Sanders is right and that if the Dems followed him they'd be in control of everything right now. Unfortunately I don't believe that. The people have spoken and the people want autocracy, xenophobia, and misogyny.

And they are happy about their choice.

This is why this country is broken beyond repair. Everything being said about this election is just window dressing. More Americans than not are just hopelessly stupid. There is no longer any way to reach them.

There has been a lot of discussion around here about how Democrats spent too much time talking over the heads of people who should be voting for them but voted for trump or other republicans. I told members of my union that Ohio republicans gave millionaires and billionaires who live here tax cuts and showed them exactly how that led to their employer's receiving less funding. Less funding means less money for wages or benefits or hiring someone to replace someone who left. How much more did I need to dumb down that conversation? Outside of Cuyahoga County, members I represented overwhelmingly told me they were voting for trump and Bernie Moreno.

Oh, and when their employer cuts back again and a handful get laid off you know what they'll say? "'The Union' didn't do anything for me." Please help me understand how I am supposed to have a shred of sympathy or empathy for them. I'll save you the time. I don't and I won't.

Over the next four years a lot of people are going to be learning some harsh and painful lessons. My heart goes out to those out there who DID understand the consequences of this election and will suffer as well, through no fault of their own. I'll probably be OK. I have a good job, make a good wage, and have two pensions and social security. I'm also a straight, white, Christian male. Unless the world ends I'll probably know where my next meal is coming from for the rest of my life. If you're one of my union members and you told me you voted for trump and in 6 months you get laid off, I'll try to conceal my glee.
 
Did someone just say that people voted for Trump because they care about themselves? Get the fuck outta here. They didn't vote for him because they care about themselves. They voted for him because they fucking hate the other, they hate women, and they love that he hates them too.
 
I think the vast majority of people only care about themselves and their situation. The people on this board are major outliers in a lot of ways.

Then why are they so pizzed about gays and trans people? Foreignors? Anyone that doesn't look, think and act like them? Banning books from their local schools and libraries?

If they only cared about themselves, that's all they'd be worrying about. But as we've seen, these people have no problem sticking their noses into the lives and situations of other people, and dictating how their lives ought to be lived also.

What affect does someone 1500 miles away getting an abortion have upon their life and situation? Absolutely none. And yet, they're just so damn concerned that that's going on. Almost to the point of obsession.
 
Last edited:
No, I don't think you get it. They're not gettable. If they would vote for Trump against any other option then there is nothing you could do to convince them otherwise. Stop thinking their gettable and start believing reality.

What changed between '16 and '20 (and, in reverse, between '20 and '24)? Biden got 81 m votes to Harris' 68 m. Dumps fell off in '24 as well, but only by 2 m. People who stayed home in '24 but voted D in '20 are not gettable?
 
Last edited:
No, I don't think you get it. They're not gettable. If they would vote for Trump against any other option then there is nothing you could do to convince them otherwise. Stop thinking their gettable and start believing reality. And reality is we hate women, we hate immigrants, and we love strong men who are *******s.

This is who we are.

The dems problem wasn’t that voters just magically switched sides, they lost 15 million votes. This isn’t even getting into all the people who just don’t vote because they realize we live under corporate dictatorship.
 
Back
Top