Gauthier would have been a good choice, too. If I had to guess, I think the voters saw the significant difference in supporting cast between Celebrini and the 4 BC forwards. Celebrini had 28 points more than the next highest forward at BU. All 4 BC guys are at 60 points or more. Also, Celebrini followed up his POY with MOP of the regional, which makes it hard to justify NOT giving it to him over Gauthier IMO. Yes, Celebrini had Lane Hutson out there often, which BC doesn't have an equivalent player for.
Any chatter on campus about what the three freshmen are thinking after this season? I know I saw one writer opine that he would be shocked if Leonard is back, which checks out in my mind - he seems absolutely ready, like Gauthier. I assume Fowler will be back - highly unusual for a goalie to be a one and done.