Snives, this is a fantastic analysis of the "cupcake quotient" for a wide range of candidates for the 12th slot in Hockey East. A decidedly non-cupcake option for HEA#12 that I raised late last year was RIT, which while it does not fall into the geography as an easy "fit", I think they'd be a great addition to the league. My guess is Commish Nigel and the HEA AD's would probably draw a line closer to the fringes of New England (say, RPI or Union, or something nearer to NYC like Army?), if they were ever to consider going out beyond Greater Boston or Connecticut? But I'm fond of the Rochester NY area, and I think they run their program better than some already in HEA. So that's my vote.
But if restricted to your proposed choices, you and I will probably agree to unite forces behind the Bentley Falcons.