Re: Wednesday NCAA Hockey - The Road to Lewiston begins - and that's no snow job!
Except that Geneseo was ranked ahead of Norwich last Tuesday and both teams lost their only game at home to ranked teams. What about that would have moved Norwich ahead of Geneseo? On the "other site" I was informed the Geneseo "crushed" Norwich in the criteria and that their #2 ranking against Norwich's #3 was justified. That would seem to imply Geneseo was in first and Norwich took the last spot ahead of Trinity.
Being somewhat provocative, but there is evidence to back this up, too.
Norwich beats Trinity in every category except WIN (and possibly RNK which was even, although there is evidence that Williams fell out of RNK and was replaced by Amherst which would give Norwich a strong edge over Trinity in that category, too), and the only category that Geneseo beat Trinity in was RNK. Thus, Trinity could be viewed as in before Geneseo, and shouldn't have beaten Norwich out. That means that Geneso was the team that slid in, not Norwich.
Comparing Norwich and Gen gives a whole bunch of comparisons that are essentially equal and one (SOS) in which Norwich has a big advantage. The committee doesn't just count comparisons, but weights them based on (among other things) the size of the differential.
Except that Geneseo was ranked ahead of Norwich last Tuesday and both teams lost their only game at home to ranked teams. What about that would have moved Norwich ahead of Geneseo? On the "other site" I was informed the Geneseo "crushed" Norwich in the criteria and that their #2 ranking against Norwich's #3 was justified. That would seem to imply Geneseo was in first and Norwich took the last spot ahead of Trinity.