Handyman
Hug someone you care about...
Season one was perfectly cromulent. The big reveal(s) was no shock to anyone but whatever. It was entertaining fantasy fair, even if fairly forgettable. Take the LotR label off of it and you'd be perfectly ok with it.
I'm only 2 episodes into season 2, so can't comment on it really. But seems like much of the same.
This is true..."ok with it" is about what I would be. I still wouldn't find it all that great and probably would have quit on it (it being LOTR is the only reason I continue) but I wouldn't find some of the things so maddening. And the thing is, I am not even that big of a LOTR guy...plenty of people know way more than I do so if I am nitpicking things and know things are off it is pretty glaring.
I think there were ways to do it, even with the limitations of the material they could use, that would have worked better. Honestly the war with Morgoth would have been more interesting. I get that then you don't have certain characters in, but it also means you don't have to shoehorn other characters in that make no sense. There is almost no material on that stuff it would have been a wide open to interpretation. I dunno parts of this remind me of the things Lucas said when making the prequels about how everything rhymes. They seem to want to tell the exact same story...slightly tweaked.
Episode 6 was alright...if I had seen the title of the episode it would have spoiled the ending. I already know who shows up rather soon (I mean Amazon spoiled that real quick) and would know it even if I didn't know the tale they are so obvious about it. I dont know how many seasons they plan to do but they have a lot of worldbuilding still to do before they can even really get to the crux of the story...The Rings of Power.