What's new
By:
USCHO Fan Forum

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

  • The USCHO Fan Forum has migrated to a new plaform, xenForo. Most of the function of the forum should work in familiar ways. Please note that you can switch between light and dark modes by clicking on the gear icon in the upper right of the main menu bar. We are hoping that this new platform will prove to be faster and more reliable. Please feel free to explore its features.

SCSU and UW: Badger hunting

Re: SCSU and UW: Badger hunting

First Time said:
Right on the line of dirty as I don't think he meant to hit him in the head, I think he was trying to go for the shoulder and missed.
Absolutely a penalty, but I don't think the intent to injure was there.
And Chuck, attacking a guy's sig line because you don't like what's in there is petty.
Click to expand...

Well he has a cross to crawl up on. Hope there's enough room with the UND fans up there. Hope you guys are a little less pathetic than they turned out to be last week.
 
Re: SCSU and UW: Badger hunting

Chuck Schwartz said:
If this is your opinion than clearly it makes no sense to continue talking about this with you because clearly you are delusional.
Click to expand...

And your comments have been the picture of level-headedness?
Exactly what I was talking about in terms of over-reacting.
It's a shame he was hit in the head, it's a clear penalty, but are you actually going to try and tell me Marvin was out to hurt him?
What possible reason would Marvin have for doing it?
 
Re: SCSU and UW: Badger hunting

Dude Love said:
Well he has a cross to crawl up on. Hope there's enough room with the UND fans up there. Hope you guys are a little less pathetic than they turned out to be last week.
Click to expand...

Define pathetic because I think your picture is under the definition.
 
Re: SCSU and UW: Badger hunting

First Time said:
And your comments have been the picture of level-headedness?
Exactly what I was talking about in terms of over-reacting.
It's a shame he was hit in the head, it's a clear penalty, but are you actually going to try and tell me Marvin was out to hurt him?
What possible reason would Marvin have for doing it?
Click to expand...

I don't think Marvin said to himself, "YEAH!! I'm going to hurt him!" But he throws his shoulder up into the head, just like he did on the Genoway hit. You simply cannot mess around with hits to the head.
 
Re: SCSU and UW: Badger hunting

sfo19 said:
Define pathetic because I think your picture is under the definition.
Click to expand...

Well the guy saying that 75% of all rapes are made up by the woman and that 90% of the women who actually are raped are "asking for it" kind of takes the cake over my opinion on Aaron Marvin.
 
Re: SCSU and UW: Badger hunting

Chuck Schwartz said:
I don't think Marvin said to himself, "YEAH!! I'm going to hurt him!" But he throws his shoulder up into the head, just like he did on the Genoway hit. You simply cannot mess around with hits to the head.
Click to expand...

Hey Chuck. Word to the wise. Take a deep breathe and let them irrationally defend their goon. In the mean time your blood pressure will go down. :D
 
Re: SCSU and UW: Badger hunting

First Time said:
And your comments have been the picture of level-headedness?
Exactly what I was talking about in terms of over-reacting.
It's a shame he was hit in the head, it's a clear penalty, but are you actually going to try and tell me Marvin was out to hurt him?
What possible reason would Marvin have for doing it?[/QUOTE]

Well this is a dumb question.

Why would Marvin want to injure Geoffrion? (I'm not saying it was intentional, I'm being hypothetical here)

Blake leads the league in goals scored, is a Hobey Baker candidate and is Wisco's captain. Taking him out takes out a large part of the Badger team.
Click to expand...
 
Re: SCSU and UW: Badger hunting

sfo19 said:
Well this is a dumb question.

Why would Marvin want to injure Geoffrion? (I'm not saying it was intentional, I'm being hypothetical here)

Blake leads the league in goals scored, is a Hobey Baker candidate and is Wisco's captain. Taking him out takes out a large part of the Badger team.
Click to expand...

If we were looking to take out one of your players, we'd have used someone who sucks or never plays. Like Mitch Ryan or Jon Ammerman. Why have our best defensive forward go out and injure people?
 
Re: SCSU and UW: Badger hunting

Chuck Schwartz said:
I don't think Marvin said to himself, "YEAH!! I'm going to hurt him!" But he throws his shoulder up into the head, just like he did on the Genoway hit. You simply cannot mess around with hits to the head.
Click to expand...

So give him a five, and if the league wants, a game, that's fair IMO.
My argument here is the total classification of Marvin as a dirty "goon" player when in the case of both hits, I don't see intent to injure is going too far.
 
Re: SCSU and UW: Badger hunting

First Time said:
So give him a five, and if the league wants, a game, that's fair IMO.
My argument here is the total classification of Marvin as a dirty "goon" player when in the case of both hits, I don't see intent to injure is going too far.
Click to expand...

What would be fair is if Marvin got knocked in the head and was gone for the season. Life isn't fair though.
 
Re: SCSU and UW: Badger hunting

First Time said:
So give him a five, and if the league wants, a game, that's fair IMO.
My argument here is the total classification of Marvin as a dirty "goon" player when in the case of both hits, I don't see intent to injure is going too far.
Click to expand...

I'd be happy with a game suspension.

I don't know, maybe it's a coincidence that both of these hits just happened to be against arguably two "would be" WCHA First Team players and captains of their respective teams.

Weird coincidence though...
 
Re: SCSU and UW: Badger hunting

Dude Love said:
If we were looking to take out one of your players, we'd have used someone who sucks or never plays. Like Mitch Ryan or Jon Ammerman. Why have our best defensive forward go out and injure people?
Click to expand...

1. He's good at it.
2. The league has shown that they won't punish him for more than 1 game.

;)
 
Re: SCSU and UW: Badger hunting

First Time said:
So give him a five, and if the league wants, a game, that's fair IMO.
My argument here is the total classification of Marvin as a dirty "goon" player when in the case of both hits, I don't see intent to injure is going too far.
Click to expand...



the Genoway hit cannot be classified in any other way than the video shows it. A deliberate and malicious hit to the head that could have easily....EASILY been avoided.

this is how, and why you get labeled a goon.

and if you don't like the label cheer for hockey players that aren't goons. I'm sure SCSU has 20-22 other guys who play good clean hard-nosed hockey. they're just not named Aaron Marvin
 
Re: SCSU and UW: Badger hunting

Dude Love said:
If we were looking to take out one of your players, we'd have used someone who sucks or never plays. Like Mitch Ryan or Jon Ammerman. Why have our best defensive forward go out and injure people?
Click to expand...



Exactly, we wouldn't use our best defensive forward, best penalty killing forward, top line center and an assistant captain.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top