Re: Obama 6(...66)
Have you considered that it might be the questioner? I'd certainly answer that question with an enthusiastic and wholehearted yes if I felt the questioner was acting in good faith, but I also might not be meaning what you meant by our founding principles. Just the fact that you seem to be playing "gotcha" is a good indicator of the reaction you should expect -- why would someone play your game?
If in the middle of a heated exchange on the separation of church and state, I challenged a religious fundamentalist "But you do you love America and the principles it was founded upon, right?" I'd expect hesitation or even belligerence from the latter, suspecting entrapment.
I think you're right that conservatives as a group fetishize The Nation. The question is where does that lead. My reading of history is: nowhere good. Unbridled national pride -- "my country, right or wrong" -- is positive only a means to a better country. The highest form of patriotism is forcing the country back from the comfortable, easy path of least resistance, pragmatism, self-righteousness and rationalization and back towards its principles, particularly in the teeth of loud, angry, violent opposition.
Everybody knows this when the principles they feel are the most important are on the line. Where they err is when they dismiss other principles as somehow not as important -- at that point it becomes easy to see reformers representing those principles as less patriotic.
And I do consider that to be a problem.
OK, I definitely need to clarify. I would never ask it if I'm having a healthy debate on specific topics of substance. The only time I've ever asked this is when the conversation has degenerated into a useless squabble over liberalism and conservatism in general. So just to be clear, if it's a civil and constructive banter, such as in your example, I would never be so blunt. You know what I mean, it's on here all the time, my initial post came from just such a thing. I guess what I'm trying to say is I wouldn't ask the question until the conversation had already sunk way below a very simple "gotcha" question.
That being said.... You're making alot of assumptions about me based on your own opinions of all conservatives - I think that's something you dressed down someone else on here, by the way. Where in the heck did I mention a single thing about "my country, right or wrong?" I think you might be stereotyping me, buddy. Or perhaps you misread my question because it certainly wasn't, "But do you love your country and stand behind every single thing it has done for the past 230 years?"
I'm also kind of confused why you're talk about principles being on the line. It's not a question of your principles or mine. It's a question of how you feel about America and its founding principles. (Although if you were somehow saying our founding principles are on the line these days, I would be in complete agreement with you.) You're spot on about it be about patriotism, but you're dead wrong about it being an accusation - it's a question.
You are also correct about the reaction to my question, at least partially. Hesitation and anger are not at all uncommon reactions from either side of the fence. The difference is between a "how dare you insult me like that" and a "that was a dirty trick, how dare you ask me something like that" kind of anger - and it's really not that hard to tell the difference, so let's not get into that debate. And regardless of initial emotional reaction, it's almost 100% of the time the liberal that's the one throwing in qualifiers while answering a general question about their patriotism.
I'm not making any claims against all liberals, or even most. I'm just saying that when I put someone on the spot and ask them how patriotic they are, those who do hedge or qualify or squirm are very nearly always liberals. Maybe I'm just randomly asking the wrong people so I have skewed results, do you think? I don't think so at all. I bet if I asked this as a stand alone question to 1000 random people, not as part of some political conversation, the results would be pretty much the same.
If you think occasionally pointing out that I love my country and the principles it was founded upon is "fetishizing The Nation" then I'd really enjoy hearing you put a fair an honest characterization of the Obama idolatry into words. Also, you better tell those liberal celebrities Bruce Springsteen and John Mellencamp to apologize for "fetishizing" with those patriotic songs of theirs, those jerks. Long story short, I'm sure you'll agree that calling it "fetishizing" is just a wee bit of an embellishment.
As far as not taking the path of least resistance and bringing the country back to its principles in the face of loud and angry opposition goes.... hmmmm, let's see....
A president who is fawned over by the far left; who has more power with his brigade of unelected, unvetted radical left czars surrounding him; who has already nationalized large chunks of the auto and financial industries; who now has his sights on nationalizing the health care industry; and who has the leaders of both houses of a filibuster-proof Congress in his pocket. All major networks except one are leaning slightly left to, in the case of MSNBC, completely ignorant left. And all major newpaper media is leaning squarely left.
So yeah... I'm a vocal proponent of bringing America closer to its founding principles - but I must say I think I'm more of the garden variety patriot, not the highest form of patriot. But thank you so much for the compliment anyway, Kepler!