Re: Minnesota High School Hockey '10-'11
I think it is time for the bbdl plan for MN high school hockey tournament format. Finally, a solution to the 2-class system, where private schools are allowed to play in single A and dominate.
The plan:
1. During the regular season, A and AA are not present, all teams play as part of one pool, but the section lines are still there, there would still be 8 sections, just with many more schools in each section.
2. At the end of the regular season, the 32 best teams in the state are chosen. You could use an RPI type system, or have a committee select the teams, dark, smokey room style. Either way, you end up with the top 32 teams in the state.
3. The remaining teams in the state compete in their section tournaments like happens now. This will still be a much larger group of teams than either section tournaments currently have, so it may lead to the regular season being shortened by 2-3 games, which I don't think is the end of the world. Also, sections like section 1, where maybe only 1-2 teams make the top 32, would have many more teams in the section than, say, section 6, which may have 5-6. Due to this, there may have to be a flexible section system, where either section lines are drawn each year after the 32 have been selected, or the option is there to shift a specified amount of teams from one section to another to even them out.
4. The top 32 play for the class AA championship, play it like the NCAA tournament, 2 weekends long. Instead of a weekend of section finals, and a weekend of state tournament, you have 2 weekends of state tournametn.
5. The rest of the teams, split into sections, go through a tournament, styled just like it is now, and play for the class A championship.
This plan does a couple things. First, it allows class AA teams that can't compete in AA, like St. Francis, Coon Rapids, Woodbury, etc. a chance to go to the state tournament. Second, it gives small schools that have that magical year, a chance at the big crown. There have been years where you could argue that the A champion is just as good as the AA champion, this is their chance to prove it.
Post 2 coming up with how it could play out this year.