Re: Detroit Tigers, Volume 1 - The Lou Whitaker version
I think we have plenty of talent on our pitching staff. It would be different if we were looking at what we had 6-7 years ago. If a pitching coach has AA-caliber talent, it's not going to matter too much what he does. I don't believe that to be the case here.
I guess I look at it from a standpoint of preparation and progression. If pitchers consistently get bombed out of the ballpark in the first couple innings, that shows a either a lack of talent on the pitcher's part, or a lack of proper preparation attributable to both the pitching coach and the pitcher. Given what we have in the rotation, I don't think it's lack of talent. We've been getting hit too hard, far too often, over too many pitchers as of late.
If a young pitcher does not show signs of progression, where you can see that over time he's getting better, at this level that tends to be pretty damning of the pitching coach. I think we're starting to see some of that with Porcello, and to a certain extent, Scherzer.
If all of a sudden the pitcher starts getting shelled, or velocity drops by a few MPH, that indicates either a flaw in mechanics or a potential injury. It's up to the pitching coach to see if there's an adjustment to be made to the mechanics, and if there isn't, well, then we know what the next course of action is. I think we might be looking at that with Porcello as well, too.
The starting pitching has gotten bombed as of late, Verlander exempted. I doubt the whole rotation has arm troubles, so that leaves either mechanics or poor game planning. Upon further review, while I liked Rick Knapp, I lay a good deal of the blame for our recent troubles at his feet. A game or two where a pitcher gets bombed out by the 4th inning, I can live with. It happens to every pitcher once in a while. But we're almost 2 weeks into going and getting the starting pitcher in the 5th inning. We had 3 or 4 straight games where we gave our starter at least 6 runs, and only once in that span was the starting pitcher able to get through 5 innings. I'll give you one good guess as to who that starter was, and no, it wasn't Phil Coke.
I hope that starts to answer some of your question.