Re: College Football III: We may lose, but we keep the score close!
Its not as crazy as it sounds. If the Big East wants to get to 10 schools with football, telling ND all in or get out just might work. If ND calls the Big East, they could kick out the other ND sports and then be able to add a whole school like say TCU. Then, what does ND do with its other sports? Cobble together schedules for Men's and Women's Basketball, Volleyball, Track, Cross Country, Softball and baseball, Swallow some pride and move those sports into the MAC? Or prehaps worst of all, come crawling on your hands and knees to the Big Ten and having to kiss their ring? Tell me what ND fan really likes that last option there??
I won't disagree that it's not crazy (hell, in all honesty, short of independence I think the Big East is ND's best option). I'm just calling it unlikely. I do not think the risk of driving Notre Dame towards the Big Ten is worth the reward of it potentially working and getting Notre Dame on board. It really would all depend on whether the Big Ten wants to go to 16 or not.
Notre Dame's "Olympic + basketball" options are not incredibly bad, all told. None of them are the Big Ten or Big East (and for the one non-football sport that matters to the Domers, the latter is preferable), but there's the A-10 (decent hoops, teams in BosNyPhiWash), Horizon (lots of local competition, good programs in Butler and Valpo, as well as two in Chicago), and Missouri Valley (good hoops, a few local teams, access to Chicago). For all it matters, Notre Dame could even pull together their own all-sports conference that suspiciously doesn't include enough teams to play football but is still quite good at hoops.
And worst-case scenario? Notre Dame gets booted, they tell the Big Ten they want in, the Big Ten goes to sixteen, and Notre Dame convinces them to take Syracuse, Rutgers, and Pitt, or maybe UConn (in any event, schools that absolutely won't turn down an invite). Oops.
The Big East is pretty afraid of that nightmare scenario coming true. There's precious little they can do to stop it, but at the very least they can not make it happen through their own actions.