Re: Brown - Oops! They did it again.
People are quick to blame everything on the kids for overlooking any issues. Brown is exactly like a bunch of d-3 schools in regards to the school itself and in a sense recruiting. I’ve seen colleges like Amherst and Middlebury ranked higher than numerous Ivies. The only difference is the competition they play in sports.
How does that not show these players are competitive athletes. This year’s freshmen and recruiting class can be blamed for deciding Brown while knowing the team is struggling, but there weren’t any clear indicators for any of the classes before them. Even if you want to argue there were, all these kids are only guilty of wanting to play d-1 and play against d-1 caliber players, even if that means not having a good record.
You're serious!?...so which is it? In your previous post, you say Digit should be fired because the team is in a 5 year slump. Then you say that other than this year's freshman class there was no indication the team was struggling (your own words!)???
I would say it has been very clear the team was struggling for a couple of seasons before that.
There is definitely nothing wrong with wanting to go to a struggling program. Whether it is to be able to play D1 hockey, or to go where you can make a bigger impact on the program, ...or choosing that school for other reasons despite the fact the team happens to be struggling.
The problem is acting all surprised and frustrated and unhappy once you get there that the team is struggling and want to lobby for a different coach because of either her coaching style, the team record, or the level of turnover--all of which were already a matter of public record.
Despite your perception, I actually don't blame it ALL on the kids. From what I can see, the kids that are still there are working hard and generally doing the best they can--and just maybe that's why they're there. They don't give up even when they are down. I think that is most certainly a credit to the players...but probably the coaches deserve at least a little of the credit for that too. It's hard to stay motivated to work hard under much adversity.
I think there
are quite a few talented kids on the team...but certainly still not nearly enough of them yet to finish significantly higher in the standings even with a different coach. That much is obvious to me, having watched a variety of other teams who are higher in the standings. So a little patience will be required regardless before this team makes the playoffs again. I think in particular the freshmen Jamieson, Farrer, Jolin and Polenska are great additions you immediately notice out there...so it appears to me the talent level is improving, and a sign of hope for the future. Getting a couple more quality D next year would help alot.
Digit also really does seem to be trying hard to change her approach. She certainly is FAR more restrained on the bench than she used to be. So I give her credit for trying to work on herself at least. That doesn't seem to me to be indicative of someone who has given up, or is not wanting to accept some personal accountability for addressing the problems. Maybe it's still not enough, I couldn't say.
I do hold the coaches responsible for the high level of turnover over an extended period of time, and the need to reduce it going forward. Turnover is generally required to rebuild, so I suspect it may be high again going into next season. As has been said many times, it would likely be even higher with a new coach. But if the team doesn't then stabilize and make forward progress, I would agree coaching changes would have to be considered as more quality recruits are beginning to chose Brown again. You just can't be in rebuilding mode forever and this team has been rebuilding for several years. And some coaches may just not have the different skillsets required to lead a successful rebuilding effort, despite their other merits.
But at the end of the day, it really doesn't matter what I think, or you think though anyway, that's for the administration to decide. All you can do is make the best of the situation in the meantime, which is the only thing you do have control over.