Re: 2010 Stanley Cup Playoffs IV: "The game puck just got Prongered"
Ah, but those magic beans eventually led to gold, no?
I do think it's fair value. Just my .02, but consider:
* Goaltenders aren't exactly at a premium right now. Plenty to be had via free agency.
Not too many high quality ones and certainly not many #1 caliber goaltenders that don't have large question marks attached (Nabokov)
* Goaltender's dont being back much in value anymore, anyhow. And why should they? It's been a while since a Cup winner had an elite goalie. Lots of talk during the playoffs about the diminishing importance of the goalie. Halak wants between 4-5M per year. You think he deserves that? Ask Vancouver how happy they are with Luongo's deal. Or Chicago with Huet's. Or Boston with Thomas.
Nobody likes paying a lot for anyone. Luongo's not all that bad and Thomas did have a bad year this year. However, of those you mentioned, only Huet was a rip off. I still don't know how he got the deal he got. He never showed anything over any prolonged period of time. The rumor is that Bowman is "taking some action" with payroll this offseason and Huet was one he was going to talk to (whatever that means). Bowman can talk to Huet all offseason if he wants. There's no way the Hawks are going to buy out Huet nor will they be able to get even a 7th round draft pick for him. He's got NO value at all right now.
* Lars Eller is a very good, near ready prospect. That's not hyperbole. He was outstanding overseas and he handled himself well for his first year here. He also fills an organizational need (Center; and one with at least some size and solid two way play).
* As for Schultz, a big guy who likes to fight? On our D? Yes please. He's a couple of years away, but yes.
Eller will make the Habs roster out of camp. I'm pretty sure. He didn't do too badly in limited action last year.
As for Schultz (a forward as was mentioned), he's a wild card. His numbers in the WHL are ok, but who knows how that will translate to the pros. He's run out of eligibility for major juniors so he'll have to be signed by the Habs. This brings into question whether or not the Habs traded for him in the first place? Maybe the Blues didn't want to sign Schultz so he was included as a throw in? Who knows.
* Once can not ignore the cap implications for Montreal with this deal, either. Halak would've cost too much. For better or worse, Carey is the man, and how much is he realistically going to cost next season? This gives them a shot at retaining Plekanec if they wish.
Only time will tell...but I'm not disappointed. Sad to see Halak go, but we all knew someone was heading out the door.
For worse. Carey Price is one of the most overrated goaltenders currently in the NHL. Everyone seems to question his maturity (look at the fact that he was shooting pucks at the Capitols in the playoffs and doing some fancy stick work to them as well). He's, yeah, I'm going to say it. He's the most inconsistent goaltender playing in the NHL.
That being said, you're right. Halak was probably going to be too expensive. And I think the Blues will find that out. Someone did indeed have to go, but I thought it would be the overrated Price going.
You don't have to be disappointed yet (if you are a Habs fan). Just wait until Price becomes the #1 goaltender again and leads them on to mediocrity or worse.
Some of the stuff reminds me of the crap that Tom Yawkey pulled when he was alive. Miserable bastiges, the both of them.
I think Down Goes Brown has convinced me to take the Leafs as my #2 NHL team.
It's funny. I check DGB before I check any other blog. He never fails to bring a smile to my face.
From
DGB: "If you'd like to make an offer, send it my way during the first two rounds. Seriously. Just come on over and pull up a chair. I'm going to be looking for something to kill the time."
hilarious.