Re: 2009 MLB Thread, Part II: Claimed Off The Waiver Wire
No.
Look closely at Ted Williams. He missed over 4 1/2 years, in the prime of his career, serving in both WWII and Korea. Imagine what
he would have done.
See for yourself
Conservatively, figure 35 homers a year from 1943-45, plus at least another 55 homers total from 1952-53. His totals go from 521 into the neighborhood of at least 680-700, depending on how conservative you want to be. He'd be #4 on the all-time list.
Now look at his hit totals. 180 hits/yr for 1943-45, plus ~ 275 for his lost year and a half (plus more) in Korea. The new hit total now approaches 3,500. Right now only 5 players have more than 3,500 hits (Rose, Cobb, Aaron, Musial, Speaker).
RBI's: same thing. 120/year for the WWII years, plus ~ 150 more total for the time spent in Korea. You're around 2,350, good for #1 on the all time list.
Now put that together. .344 average, 680 HR, 2,350 RBI, 3,500 H. The only hitter that approaches those numbers wore #3 in Yankee Stadium. And then figure in what would have happened had Ruth not spent the majority of his first six seasons as a pitcher, even in the dead ball era. He might still be the all-time home run king. He essential hit his homers over a 16-year period (688 homers between 1919-1934, the years where he played full-time in the field).