Not even consistency between USA’s men’s team and women’s team, though that’s not really their fault entirely; From what I’ve heard, they tried to get current athletes from Plattsburgh, Middlebury, Elmira, etc., but the coaches said “no” across the board, whereas the DIII men’s coaches almost universally embraced this as a good opportunity for the athletes involved. The end result for the USA women was a roster primarily made up of 2022 graduates who aren’t actively playing anymore, so weren’t anywhere near mid-season shape.
is that an excuse for a 5th-place finish that saw them miss out on the trip to Lake Placid? Not really - recent DI graduates should still be able to play at a high level - but it definitely contributed.
It's a lot easier for men's teams to play without one or two of their best for a couple of weeks. Plattsburgh men went 4-0 without Jack Ring. I don't know that Plattsburgh women beat Midd, Oswego twice or even Canton without Sierra Benjamin or Nicole Unsworth (the two most likely players they probably wanted) in those games.
I'm not sure that they will be as insistent on active NCAA players next tournament since it will be in Italy and not the US, but USA Hockey needs to coordinate better with the NCAA on a league-wide break if they expect active players from the best programs.