Badger Booster
Registered User
Re: WCHA Thread III
I tend to agree with this train of thought. If the award was WCHA Offensive Player of the Year, then it would be hard to argue against JLam. However, it's Player of the Year which, ideally, factors in other issues like defense and perhaps leadership. Those could be the issues, instead of a league-wide conspiracy against someone.
Same potential situation with MLam on defense. Yes, a big time scorer from the blueline, but is she great defensively? I don't really know.
I tend to agree with this train of thought. If the award was WCHA Offensive Player of the Year, then it would be hard to argue against JLam. However, it's Player of the Year which, ideally, factors in other issues like defense and perhaps leadership. Those could be the issues, instead of a league-wide conspiracy against someone.
Same potential situation with MLam on defense. Yes, a big time scorer from the blueline, but is she great defensively? I don't really know.
Brad nailed the argument? I actually don't think you're entitled to win WCHA Player of the Year because you won the league scoring title by 10 points, just because lots of other WCHA Players of the Year also won the scoring title by a similar margin. None of the other players mentioned there were on a team that finished a distant third in the league.
There's a case to be made for JLam as WCHA Player of the Year, but I don't like the claim that JLam absolutely must have personally offended other coaches. There's a case to be made for Decker as well (e.g. points against the top 4 teams.)
I do object more to MLam being on the Second Team.