We need to stop with the legacy hires. Hasn’t worked for hockey or football which has done it again. We need new blood
So, I kind of agree with some of this, and don't necessarily agree with other parts of it. Starting with Football, I don't know that you can say hires from within the UNH Football family tree haven't worked out? Going back to Bill Bowes in the early '70's coming over from Penn State, and then leading the program for over a quarter century, and leaving his job in his mid 50's as the winningest football coach in UNH history, he felt compelled to pass the job along to UNH alum and his top assistant Sean McDonnell. All McDonnell did was go on to coach for almost another quarter century, finishing as the second winningest coach in UNH history, with a coaching tree that would choke a fair-sized horse. Next up was UNH alum Ricky Santos, and while he was marginally less successful than his UNH mentor, he never had a losing season, and he's parlayed it into the HC job at Ivy League Penn. Goodrich is a younger Santos, we'll see how he does, but the decisions over the last 50+ years at UNH Football have been infinitely better than the decisions made for UNH Hoops, which have been mostly outsiders.
With Hockey, I'll start at Holt (I leave all pre-Holt stuff to Snives) and like Bowes, he came from away, but made UNH his destination and home, and we were all the better for it. Kullen came from within Holt's extended UNH family, and was by all accounts on his way to turning things around from the sad crash of the late Holt era when fate intervened, yet it was another guy from inside the UNH program (Umile) who took over the program for a quarter century of his own, and exceeded even Coach Holt's accomplishments. Umile was poised to make the next choice, but events of the previous seasons prior to his retirement all made the succession issue far more difficult. Separating from Borek in favor of Souza was a fatal error in judgment, and I'm not sure why it happened, but as both Borek and Jimmy T left the program in the years leading up to Umile's retirement, those errors are both on Umile's part. And that's not even touching on the biggest "what if?" in the program's history, which is why Blue Skies needlessly fired McCloskey from the Women's post, effectively exiling him from any consideration to succeed Umile. And Coach Lassonde had by then moved West as well.
Had Umile made his choice from amongst the pool of McCloskey, Borek, Lassonde and Tortorella, does anyone really think UNH Hockey would have fallen so far, so fast? Just keeping Borek and Tortorella around instead of phasing them out in effect for Stewart and then Souza, would have prevented the dramatic fall from grace in Umile's final 3 seasons, which we not-so-fondly recall as the "Quest for the NRN". Anyone who listened to the Boyle interview about Parker earlier this week will note how little importance a top winner like Parker gave to his own NRN, but it apparently mattered to Umile, who lacked Parker's NC's.
It would be fascinating to put Umile on truth serum, and find out why he effectively ditched his experienced and qualified assistants in favor of the younger and unproven Stewart/Souza UNH alum duo ... and also to find out why he didn't fight harder with Blue Skies to prevent him from the obvious overreaction with McCloskey??? For a guy who used good judgment over a long stretch of years at UNH, it's hard not to conclude Umile's ego got the better of him.
Does that all mean it would be a mistake for UNH to draw from their pool of alum candidates? I don't necessarily think so. Personally, I would love to see an energetic guy with NHL playing/AHL coaching pedigree like Eric Boguniecki get a chance to turn this around. It wouldn't devastate me if Jimmy T took over on an interim basis next season to see how that worked, and to otherwise give the program some time to vet a bunch of ambitious experienced guys out there.
But this ongoing parade of mediocrity has to come to an end. Every false dawn inevitably turns into the latest mirage of progress. How many more times, AD f/k/a SB????