What are you using for metrics to support that opinion? Their NHL points per game are essentially identical at 0.66 points per game, although Sharp has 142 more games than JvR, so the latter will need to keep up that pace for a couple more NHL seasons.
In the words of WEEI's immortal Glenn Ordway ... "You're making, my point". ;-)
Ultimately, it's not even close, although the PPG thing is eerily similar. One guy came in as a heralded top of the first round draft pick, and has really accomplished nothing of note. At best, he's met expectations, an above-average scoring forward with average or worse teams for most of his career, and has never (not once) skated in an All-Star Game. Sharp exceeded expectations for a 3rd round pick, was an integral part of three (3) Stanley Cup champions in Chicago, and even made an All Star game once (and apparently performed really well in it, per the linked video below). Ironically, both JvR and Sharp were originally drafted by Philadelphia, but went on to have their best years elsewhere. Not that it matters/is relevant, but Sharp has also set the bar pretty high for post-hockey JvR to meet.
JvR's career is no doubt on its back nine, and unless he's willing to take a significant pay cut to be a spare part and/or PP specialist on a Cup contender, I don't see much of a chance for him to overtake Sharp's accomplishments overall. Anyone here is free to disagree, but I think it will take some doing to convince me I'm on the wrong side of this debate.
But, here is my question of the day. Are those who are unwilling to attend games at the Whitt if there is a mask mandate really just looking for an excuse not to watch a poorly coached bad hockey team get embarrassed game after game at home?
I think you may have gone a long way towards answering your own question, Snives.
In short, I've had my shots, and was told when I had those shots that my life could return to normal. Anyone going back on that promise is lacking in good faith, so I'm sorry, but I'm not playing along any longer. I have a choice on whether to start going back to watching college hockey live this season OR eking out another season of coaching travel team soccer, which is now standing at 20 years of service. The last couple of seasons, coaching has admittedly been a grind at times, and I was pretty ill (non-Wuhan Flu) for about six months this past season with the effects of a tick-borne illness, from which I've only recently begun to return to my pre-illness activity levels (i.e. playing Over 50 soccer and considering coaching again).
The way things played out last season coaching-wise, it was the first time I had to turn over head coaching duties to an assistant during that stretch (other than for an odd game here or there), and I skipped the usual summer league season as well. So, pretty much all the signs were there for me to call it a career at this point ... and I may yet still, but now with the stupidity at the rinks ongoing at the college level - and frankly, there may be no end in sight, I can see masks at The Whitt for another 5+ years (y'know, seasonal flu is pretty bad too etc. rolleyes) - it may be time to rethink coaching retirement, and pull out the stops to see if I can make it to the NRN in honor of Coach Umile, which would also be to the RBRN. ;-)