Damn, you're as old as me, if you remember THAT!
My Dad was from Maine. For whatever reason, he loved Johnny Unitas, and that made me a Baltimore fan.
I was a kid when Broadway Joe won that one. It still hurts to remember Orr all alone in the end zone during the opening drive.
I'll get over it someday, or not.
This looks like a fun, harmless discussion I can add to, as I'm about the same age as you guys then. My first front-to-end Super Bowl watched was SB IV a year later, when the Chiefs upset the Vikings. First, background ...
My Dad was a Lombardi/Packers fan during the '60's (fortuitous timing, eh?), and Unitas came to fame in the late '50's when his Colts teams beat the NY Giants twice in a row in the NFL Championship Game (pre-AFL predecessor to the Super Bowl) in '58 and '59. Starr stepped up after that and dominated the '60's once Lombardi was established in GB, with six (6) trips to the title game in eight years ('60-'61-'62 and '65-'66-'67), and winning all but the '60 game to Philly, when Jim Taylor was tackled by Chuck Bednarik inside the 10 yard line as time expired (it turned out to be the only NFL postseason game Lombardi lost). GB just missed a two-team postseason in '63 (Hornung gambling scandal) and '64, and in modern days they would have easily qualified as a wild card. Baltimore missed the playoffs most of those years, despite some very good seasons, since they and GB were in the same division. You literally had to win your division to make the one game postseason back then.
Back then, both pre-AFL and during the pre-merger AFL, the NFL's national network was CBS (the AFL was mostly NBC), and for many years, CBS would telecast NY Giants' games into all of New England as their "home territory". And even after the Boston Patriots were born in 1960, they were mostly dog food for the pre-merger AFL years - only Denver was clearly worse. So it took a long (long) time in many areas for the local allegiances to shift from being Giants' fans to Patriots' fans (FWIW I'm a Giants fan dating back to '69 since they were on TV every week). The then-Washington Redskins had a similar territorial arrangement with the Southern states, until NFL expanded into Atlanta (1966) and New Orleans (1967), and the AFL moved into Miami (1967?). But there was a sizeable amount of New England pro football fans who did not ascribe to adopting the hated New York team(s) as their "home" teams - as an aside, the Patriots rarely sold out wherever their home stadium was at the time, be it BU or Fenway or BC or Harvard - so even the Jets were a 2nd choice "home" team when the Patriots' home games were invariably blacked out from local telecast.
My Dad was one of those resisters - and perhaps yours was as well, Fishy? Johnny U would have held strong favor among those folks for the Colts beating the Giants in '58 and '59, just as my Dad worshipped Lombardi for thrashing the Giants in '61 and '62 for his first of five titles that decade. "The enemy of my enemy is my friend", about two generations ago. Ironically, St. Vincent of Lombardi (I'm still a Giants fan, but a dedicated convert to the Church of Lombardi) was one of the loudest, most obnoxious New Yorkers of his time!
With the Chiefs and Patrick Mahomes about to tee up a season where they will seek to become the first team to ever win three Super Bowls in a row, you guys may be hearing about the "first ever" thing without questioning it. Lombardi's GB Packers won 3 straight NFL titles in '65-'66-'67 which was treated as a heroic triumph at the time. There was no Super Bowl after the '65 season, but if there were one, you'd absolutely have to suspend disbelief to think the '65 Buffalo Bills would have put a serious paw on the Packers - not after how the older Packers' teams throttled better Chiefs and Raiders teams in the first two SB's. It was also the reason why the Jets beating the 13-1 Colts in Super Bowl 3 was such a shocking upset. And if Johnny U wasn't injured for SB3, there's a very good chance your Baltimore Colts would have continued the dominance.
To modernize this for folks younger than us, probably the best comparison I can offer for Unitas is that he was "Payton Manning" to Bart Starr's "Tom Brady" 40 or so years apart. Despite all of Starr's postseason success, I think Unitas was universally heralded as the greatest QB in NFL history, at least until Joe Montana dominated the '80's. Your dad had excellent taste in NFL QB's, Fishy, and there was plenty of reason for him to do so.
