What's new
USCHO Fan Forum

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

  • The USCHO Fan Forum has migrated to a new plaform, xenForo. Most of the function of the forum should work in familiar ways. Please note that you can switch between light and dark modes by clicking on the gear icon in the upper right of the main menu bar. We are hoping that this new platform will prove to be faster and more reliable. Please feel free to explore its features.

The 2011 Budget of the United State - Alice, you're not going to the moon!

Re: The 2011 Budget of the United State - Alice, you're not going to the moon!

I am still not convinced WE are serious about stopping terrorism.
 
Re: The 2011 Budget of the United State - Alice, you're not going to the moon!

I am still not convinced WE are serious about stopping terrorism.

Who's we in this sentence? Cause I still have yet to be asked by my President to sacrifice anything for the cause. Bush told me to go shopping. What he didn't ask me to do is pay a war tax, or allow my representatives in Congress to declare War.

Obama is much of the same.
 
Re: The 2011 Budget of the United State - Alice, you're not going to the moon!

dx,

No it isnt a joke...he is saying even the most noble are willing to do very immoral things. It all comes down to what it means to you.

And Scooby, I meant our country mainly our government. Things are always easier when you have a boogyman to fight against and there will ALWAYS be terrorism. It isnt like it just showed up out of the blue one day but no one takes North Korea or China seriously and we need someone to point to and call evil and as luck would have it...
 
Re: The 2011 Budget of the United State - Alice, you're not going to the moon!

IMO the international community should see a worldwide military freeze as a priority...just as with the environment or IBMs. Start with a cap on military spending...and move later to reductions. It only benefits everyone.

Dude. Arms are the only thing we make that anybody wants. Ixne on the eezefre. ;)
 
Re: The 2011 Budget of the United State - Alice, you're not going to the moon!

And Scooby, I meant our country mainly our government. Things are always easier when you have a boogyman to fight against and there will ALWAYS be terrorism. It isnt like it just showed up out of the blue one day but no one takes North Korea or China seriously and we need someone to point to and call evil and as luck would have it...

It all comes down to votes. Now that it exists (war on terror) it can be used as a political football by the left and right to further polarize the country. Same with a lot of other issues. Taxes, abortion, energy, etc. Nothing ever gets done because someone that's rich has a very good reason (money) for a particular problem to stay status quo.
 
Re: The 2011 Budget of the United State - Alice, you're not going to the moon!

You say that like you think that military spending will somehow "solve" the Al Qaeda problem. Is it just that we haven't yet spent enough, then?

You say that like you think there's no way to win, so let's just quit trying.

There are legitimate things for the government to spend money on. National defense is one of them. That's not to say that the national defense budget doesn't deserve scrutiny, but just arbitrarily calling for its freeze or to slash it when there's so much else to start with is kind of a joke from where I've been.
 
Re: The 2011 Budget of the United State - Alice, you're not going to the moon!

Isn't funny how everyone wants the government to cut the budget until it's something that they want or think the country needs?

Cracks me up.
 
Re: The 2011 Budget of the United State - Alice, you're not going to the moon!

There are legitimate things for the government to spend money on. National defense is one of them. That's not to say that the national defense budget doesn't deserve scrutiny, but just arbitrarily calling for its freeze or to slash it when there's so much else to start with is kind of a joke from where I've been.

Nobody's saying give up our ability defend ourselves. But as times change, the cold war wraps up, the economy becomes more global...countries are looking to prosper economically, not so much militarily. The following is a budget chart from Wiki showing the US military budget adjusted for inflation.

500px-PerCapitaInflationAdjustedDefenseSpending.PNG


Note that even as the cold war has ended and direct international threats requiring a large military have eased , our budget has not let up. This is the problem.
 
Re: The 2011 Budget of the United State - Alice, you're not going to the moon!

Isn't funny how everyone wants the government to cut the budget until it's something that they want or think the country needs?

Cracks me up.

Me, too. If by cracking up you mean, "weeping for our future." :(

I know you're over it by now, but I'm still clinging to a shred of hope. I should just give up and join you - probably a lot less frustrating.
 
Re: The 2011 Budget of the United State - Alice, you're not going to the moon!

You say that like you think there's no way to win, so let's just quit trying.
Um, no. I said that maintaining current levels of military spending won't allow us to beat Al Qaeda. How did you manage to twist that into my saying that nothing would ever work?

There are legitimate things for the government to spend money on. National defense is one of them. That's not to say that the national defense budget doesn't deserve scrutiny, but just arbitrarily calling for its freeze or to slash it when there's so much else to start with is kind of a joke from where I've been.

Sacred Cow - it's what's for dinner. :rolleyes:
 
Re: The 2011 Budget of the United State - Alice, you're not going to the moon!

You say that like you think there's no way to win, so let's just quit trying.

There are legitimate things for the government to spend money on. National defense is one of them. That's not to say that the national defense budget doesn't deserve scrutiny, but just arbitrarily calling for its freeze or to slash it when there's so much else to start with is kind of a joke from where I've been.

To be fair, though, the national defense budget makes up nearly half of the discretionary budget ($660B out of $1.36T). While there's plenty of other areas to slash, you can't make a dent in the debt without cutting the defense budget too.

It's like states trying to balance the books without cutting education budgets - it's really hard to do when you refuse to cut the single largest piece of the puzzle.

Or for a personal example, now that i'm repaying student loans, that money has to come from somewhere. Even though food is a legitimate thing to spend money on, I still cut my food budget by not eating out as much, brown-bagging lunches, etc.
 
Re: The 2011 Budget of the United State - Alice, you're not going to the moon!

dangit jim. how we goin to devlop warp drives.

I wonder about the predator drones and the guys/gals flying them 7000 miles away (I wonder if they get hazard pay). why couldn't we do the same thing with ground based tanks/ATV.
 
Re: The 2011 Budget of the United State - Alice, you're not going to the moon!

It's like states trying to balance the books without cutting education budgets - it's really hard to do when you refuse to cut the single largest piece of the puzzle.

Who's refusing? All I'm saying is that just arbitrarily saying we need a national defense spending freeze, and the rest of the world should follow suit, is pretty foolish.
 
Re: The 2011 Budget of the United State - Alice, you're not going to the moon!

Um, no. I said that maintaining current levels of military spending won't allow us to beat Al Qaeda. How did you manage to twist that into my saying that nothing would ever work?

Well, one good twist deserves another, I always say. :rolleyes:

Sacred Cow - it's what's for dinner. :rolleyes:

Yeah, like education, social security, welfare, etc. etc. :rolleyes:
 
Re: The 2011 Budget of the United State - Alice, you're not going to the moon!

Well, one good twist deserves another, I always say. :rolleyes:

Yeah, like education, social security, welfare, etc. etc. :rolleyes:

Cut away. I have no sacred cows. Education, welfare, Social Security, Medicare. I don't care about any of it.

:rolleyes: right back at ya.
 
Re: The 2011 Budget of the United State - Alice, you're not going to the moon!

dx,

No it isnt a joke...he is saying even the most noble are willing to do very immoral things. It all comes down to what it means to you.

Yeah, i get that. I"m asking does he really think driving an F-150 is going to wreck the lives of "billions" of people. Which on its face is beyond preposterous.

When china is firing up a new coal plant every week or so everyone in in the US could drive a hummer and it wouldn't even spike beyond the background noise in the CO2 levels.

Edit: I wonder if he's ever driven in a minnesota/midwest winter...
 
Re: The 2011 Budget of the United State - Alice, you're not going to the moon!

Who's refusing? All I'm saying is that just arbitrarily saying we need a national defense spending freeze, and the rest of the world should follow suit, is pretty foolish.

I believe I was the one who advanced the issue...

and seems to me I was saying that we need to reach an agreement on a world defense spending freeze. As the US pays about half the world's military budget...this sounds like a pretty good idea to me.
 
Re: The 2011 Budget of the United State - Alice, you're not going to the moon!

Ha I wonder where anti-gravity is at... theoritically possible speculation or impossible pipe dream.

http://www.nasa.gov/centers/glenn/technology/warp/warpstat_prt.htm

84561main_warp40s.gif

84501main_speculat.gif



So we're spending $18billion for NASA and $7billion for TSA. If I had my way TSA would be disbanded and sent back to private screeners making minimum wage and NASA budget will include mission to Mars and Jupiter. Dang the soft image on "terror" and "security". Obama lacks vision, where is the "I have a dream" "Ask what you can do for your country" "we do it not because it's easy but because it's hard" speeches.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transportation_Security_Administration
Failure of TSA screeners to detect fake bombs brought through security by undercover TSA agents, with detection levels much lower than private security agents on the same tests. In the most recent tests, conducted in 2006, security screeners at LAX failed to identify 75% of fake bombs, while Chicago O'Hare screeners missed 60% of the bomb components. Private screeners in San Francisco missed only 20% of the prospective bomb parts.[29]
 
Re: The 2011 Budget of the United State - Alice, you're not going to the moon!

Yes. Worthless. This one program out of our entire budget over the past 15 years has cost as much as the Russians and Chinese spend on their entire defense budgets in a year. We give the military unlimited money to play with all sorts of technology to fight a war that will never happen, or if it comes, will be followed by us all digging out of the rubble and trying to rediscover fire. Is there really a realistic scenario where our technological best is going to face the Russian or Chinese best where we actually walk away without our planet glowing in space? We could cut the defense budget in half and still outspend the Russians and Chinese combined 3-1. I don't even think that includes the day-to-day operations in Iraq and Afghanistan.


Keep in mind that we've never had much real-time clue as to what Russia and China spend on defense.
 
Back
Top