I skated outdoors as a kid too, and even tried my hand at building an outdoor skating rink in the backyard, even though my mom was incorrectly afraid of some permanent damage to the grass or her flowers, or something. And Gurt did touch on my mindset pretty well too. I think the outdoor stuff is over done in that for the majority of people virtually all of their hockey is played indoors. And for what hockey they did play outdoors, it was done on well maintained rinks, often in public parks (like the two in my neck of the woods) and not so much on the proverbial pond.
At one time every single house in Indiana had a hoop up somewhere. Nailed to the barn. Beside the driveway. Over the garage. In Michigan (where I grew up) too. We had one over the garage, and the first purchase I ever made for the first house I ever bought was a basketball hoop that my dad and installed. I didn't know any kid that didn't play his or her fair share of driveway basketball. Yet it was only when hockey started playing their 50 or 60 over publicized outdoor games a year that we've seen basketball try to cash in and play a few. There were at least a couple (men's and women's, Notre Dame scheduled one) at the beginning of this season.
It's interesting to me to see 100,000 people watching a hockey game. There's nothing wrong with an event for the event's sake, or a little spectacle, if you call it that and only that. I just don't like the way it is presented as some return to a nostalgic time that few actually took part in, and for those that did, the overwhelming majority of their hockey was still indoors and well organized.
We have outdoor high school hockey games every year as part of Hockey Day Minnesota and they are a big hit. Pond hockey is pretty big in Minny too and the World Pond Hockey Championships played in Minneapolis every year are really well attended. There has been a lot of clamoring herefor a Gopher outdoor game and for a Winter Claasic.
So, I guess I disagree. I think it depends on the situation and where you are at.
As for the nostalgia comment, again, it depends on the situation and where you are from. The Gophers played outdoors for years in the early days before the program became a sanctioned varsity sport, so it does go back to the old days of outdoor hockey for our program.
<b><u>Minneapolis Ariel, February 16, 1895. Page 5:</u></b>
<I>
“The University of Minnesota hockey team will play a game for the championship of Minneapolis against the Minneapolis Hockey Club at their rink, at the corner of Fourth Avenue and Eleventh Street South. The game is preparatory to the game to be played Monday afternoon by Winnipeg and the University of Minnesota. Winnipeg is champion of the world.* Winnipeg has returned from a rough trip through eastern Canada and has defeated without too much trouble Montréal, Toronto, Victoria, Ottawa, Québec, and the Limestone’s. The University started practice two or three weeks ago and played against a Minneapolis team, being defeated 4-1. A week and one half ago that they defeated the same team 6-4. Tonight they play the tie off for the championship. Dr. H.A. Parkyn has been coaching the boys every afternoon. He has a couple of stars in Willis Walker and Russell.
Walker plays point and Russell cover-point, with Van Campen in goal. Parkyn
and Albert are center forwards. Dr. Parkyn’s long experience with the Victoria
team of Toronto, one of the best, makes him a fine player. Thompson and
Head, the other two forwards, are old ice polo players and skate fast and pass
well. Van Campen, quarterback on last year's football team, plays goal well.
Many tickets have been sold for tonight’s and also Monday's game. Tickets
are $.25, ladies come free. The excitement of these games is intense, and
surpasses that at a football game.”
</I>
<IMG SRC="http://i209.photobucket.com/albums/bb28/VintageMinnesotaHockey/Ice%20Arenas/AthleticParkMinneapolis.jpg"></>