I would disagree based on the second period alone, and a little bit more than that. They look completely disconnected and incoherent as a team the entire second period. If not for Diebold making some excellent saves, this game could have been tied, and quickly. Being a man up at a lot of times seemed to be basically pointless, as we were looking for that perfect setup in our own zone that never came. They need to start actually MOVING when they are a man up; seems like they get more scoring chances when they are a man down!
That being said, not the worst effort I've seen from RPI this season at all. They need to tighten the screws on special teams play. And they need to not do what I call the "Polacek PP": pass the puck to Polacek and he'll put it in the net. Substitute "Haggerty" for "Polacek" and you have the modern version, taking four or five of the same shot on the man advantage and wondering why it doesn't go in.
On another note, surprisingly, short of one bad call and a few strange ones, the reffing wasn't nearly as bad as it usually is.