Re: Quinnipiac Bobcats 09-10: Part II
This is my first post here. I'm a senior at Quinnipiac University, and I've seen four years of ups and downs with the men's ice hockey team. I am in the group that believes that Rand Pecknold should lose his job at the end of the season.
Pecknold did a stellar job in the transition from Division-II to Division-I. He did a fine job when the team gained entry into the ECAC. But at some point, reputation and prior glories are overshadowed by current failures.
The team played out of their minds through the first few weeks of the 2009-10 season. They were explosively hot, and they beat some of the best teams in the nation, including a sweep at nationally-ranked Ohio State and a great comeback victory over #12 UMass. Then it all went to hell in a hurry.
I'm not saying Pecknold should lose his job for this season alone, although anyone could make a logical case for that. I'm saying that Pecknold should lose his job because for the last five seasons, the team has started hot, gone into a funk, and fallen apart towards the end of the season, when the games matter most.
2005-06
Team starts 8-2-0. Then from November 11 to January 14, the team goes on a 3-11-0 cold streak. The team is eliminated from the ECAC Quarterfinals.
2006-07
The team starts 8-4-4. Then from January 19 to February 24, the team goes on a 5-7-1 cold streak. The team is eliminated in the ECAC Championship, catching fire in the ECAC Playoffs.
2007-08
The team starts 14-5-3 and is ranked as high as 14th in the nation. Then from January 25 to March 1, the team goes on a 3-8-1 cold streak. The team is eliminated in the ECAC Quarterfinals, including a humiliating 11-0 loss at Harvard.
2008-09
The team starts 11-6-1. Then from January 31 to February 27, the team goes on a 1-6-1 cold streak. The team is eliminated in the ECAC Quarterfinals.
2009-10
The team starts 12-1-0 and is ranked as high as 4th in the nation. Then from December 4 to February 20, the team goes on a 3-14-2 cold streak, dropping from top-five national ranking to not even receiving votes within two months.
Pecknold oversaw each of those collapses. At some point, Jack McDonald and Bill Mecca will have to look past their personal relationship with Pecknold and acknowledge the business side of college hockey. People on this forum complain about fans leaving early and giving up hope, but it's not like the team has given the fan base any great inspiration lately. I can't blame the fans for bailing on a team that has so quickly and so suddenly fallen apart.
I don't know who the replacement should be. Ben Syer, perhaps? Who knows. All I know is that change has to happen from top to bottom with this team, and it has to start at the top.
Let's go year by year
'05-'06 - This team ridiculously outperformed expectations. You weren't here yet -- let me explain. Not only were we picked to finish last in the league, the talk around campus was "Let's hope to not go 0-22 in this great league."
Not only did they win games in the league, they went ON THE ROAD and won a playoff series. Not only that, they won the first game of ANOTHER PLAYOFF SERIES ON THE ROAD, and couldn't win a second game or else they would have advanced to the ECAC Final Four in the first year in the league. This team did not have the talent to compete at the level they needed to, won with heart, and went about as far as they could go.
'06-'07 - They were 18 minutes away from the NCAA Tournament. End of story.
'07-'08 - The 11-0 loss was bad, but how about coming back after that and winning the following night. If they had given up on the season, they would have followed that up with a 14-0 loss.
Oh, and they lost that season because the refs didn't see the puck go into the net halfway through the third period, would have tied the game. Instead, Harvard ended the season by getting a goal that went in off one of their kids' chests. Here's more on that game. It was a fluke loss, to say the least:
http://wqaqsports.wordpress.com/2008/03/17/controversy-shorthanded-goal-help-doom-bobcats/
Not trying to spread one ofmy stories arbitrarily, just trying to explain how weird a game it was. That team may have been a referee's call away from going to a second straight ECAC Final Four.
'08-'09 -The team severely lacked leadership. I guess you can blame Rand for that, but that senior class was one of the best in Quinnipiac history, in terms of the players. Hard to blame Rand, just didn't have kids that were good leaders. They sure could play, though.
'09-'10 - This team was picked by the media to finish 11th in the league. For a week, they were 4th in the nation. Now, they're playing like the 11th best team in the league. Freshmen are streaky, "gump" happens. Not Rand's fault -- this class is a great recruiting class, and they will do good things for this program.
Oh, and just for kicks, let's take a look at QU's record for these years:
'05-'06 - 20-18-1
'06-'07 - 21-14-5
'07-'08 - 20-15-4
'08-'09 - 18-18-3
'09-'10 - 15-15-2 with at least 4 games remaining
They also had a streak of 20 or more wins in 9 of 10 seasons. They were one of 3 or 4 teams in all of college hockey to do that.
The idea that Rand is even on the hot seat, much less should actually be fired is so beyond flawed, it isn't even funny.