So, I downloaded Caught in the Act last night, listened to it some last night, and some more during my drive in this morning (yes, I did actually go in to work eventually). It does a pretty good job of capturing the feel of an Eric Church concert, but there are alot of things that I think you'd miss if you haven't actually seen a concert. For example, the start of Springsteen, the piano solo is actually EC sitting in the middle of the stage playing the piano and singing with one single spotlight on him. Sinners Like Me is EC sitting on a barstool with an acoustic guitar with the spotlight on him. Much of the other stuff shows through, like how much he engages the crowd, except you don't get as much of the feeling of how genuine he is, and the feeling that he absolutely loves what he's doing and his fans like you do at the show. All of this is to be expected, obviously you can't get all of that on an audio recording, so considering that, I think the CD is pretty dang excellent. My only complaint is that Carolina isn't on it. That is one of my favorites, and of the 3 EC concerts I've been to, it has only been played once, in Mankato. I could do without Jack Daniels or Country Music Jesus, and would rather hear Love Your Love the Most or Ain't Killed Me Yet or 2 Pink Lines or Hell on the Heart or Like Jesus Does(this wasn't a hit when this CD was recorded, understandable) or What I Almost Was, but overall, its good.