Me too. I watch a lot of Dragnet. Bear with me. I love the show (particularly the radio version) because it has the beautiful, spare writing style of a Raymond Chandler novel or a Charles Lederer screenplay. But I also really admire the clean, Aristotelian logic that comes out in Joe Friday's thinking and his (frequent) speechifying. There's that same backbeat of rationality and appealing to the angels of our better nature in the great westerns and the great political dramas of the 1950's and 1960's. And that was the mental furniture of my father's and older brother's and to some extent my generation.
Now, does that still exist? Sure, it must -- someplace, although I don't see it on the small or large screen (but I'm probably not looking in the right places). People have been decrying the role models of the young for as long as there have been the young. Since those role models are now... gulp... us, I hope we try our best to display some of that clean and solid logic, tempered by patience, generosity of spirit, and empathy. Better to be too soft than too hard. The Nazis didn't come from nowhere -- they had 50 years of a slow, conscience-dulling drumbeat of ideological preparation for their crimes, and most of their philosophical precursors would have been horrified by what they did. Across multiple generations an entire nation acted out the plot of "Rope" -- the calm professors playing with a hypothetical and the eager young students taking it to heart and, finally, making it real.
If Stewart was trying to "rally the base" wouldn't he have gone out of his way to prop Obama up in that interview?
Normally I'd say yes. But I think that interview goes VERY differently if this was a presidential election year. Although, I think Stewart is actually intellectually honest for the most part. Can't say so much for the hacks on primetime cable news. Some you can, I suppose.
Somebody referred to Stewart as the gate keeper for the disappointed left. He was/is hard on the President because he thinks Obama hasn't done enough. Hasn't lived up to the hype (as if any president could). In the clips I've seen, the president seemed smaller and very defensive. And getting referred to as "dude" was not a historic moment. That's what you get on a comedy show, of course. Still, I'm not comfortable with that kind of disrespect for a president, even one I rarely agree with.
Well, that's what you get when you act like you're young and hip and try to blend in with the "cool, young crowd." He made his own bed there.
A+ for mentioning "Rope." Any chance those two guys were gay? lol. John Wayne also spoke to those virtues: "Are you Jacob McCandles? I thought you wuz dead." "Not hardly"
I think you have to look harder to find the examples you mentioned, but they're still out there. In many ways we've become a nation of Tevyes, "on the other hand, on the other hand, on the other hand." We're far more equivocal, far more inclined to feel the necessity of explaining or watering down criticism or stand-taking. "He's a drug addicted murderer, although I understand he comes from a deprived socio-economic background, was abused as a child, and had no opportunity for an Ivy League education."
Well, that's what you get when you act like you're young and hip and try to blend in with the "cool, young crowd." He made his own bed there.
There's some of that, but I also think we've become a nation of the foreman from 12 Angry Men. Not quite so hasty to judgment and willing to stand against "common sense" when something doesn't smell right. And I mean this on both sides, of course. There have been plenty of lone conservatives who have had to hold out against knee jerk progressives, quietly but forcefully making their points and refusing to be cowed, until all the evidence was sifted. Rooting for the outnumbered is another tradition of all those old great films.
On John Wayne, one of the most disheartening scenes in any movie for what it says about us is the moment in Raiders when Indiana shoots the guy with the sword. Yeah, I know all of what that scene is about, but although it was genuinely funny, I have always thought, "no way does John Wayne ever shoot that guy. He puts his hand on his gun and the guy puts the sword up and walks away." And for some reason that moment sticks in my craw and I think about it when some of our more casually violent actions of public policy play out
I am glad to see Father Guido Sarducci is still kicking, but he's running really long.
And what an appropriate kick-off.
Sorry. Still a fan of Stewart/Colbert. But this was just boring.
Someone said we now need a Rally to Restore Comedy.
The Wednesday after the midterms people will start ramping up in Iowa and NH. That's usually good for a couple years' worth of comedy.
3 years at minimum. Two years of campaigning, one year of people whining and b*tc hing about how two states like Iowa and NH are so important...