Back in the day, a lot of athletes had leadership positions within the Corps. Prior commandants have made this next to impossible (hoping for improvement under Col. McCullough). There’s a narrative that Corps athletes are “getting out of” training, when in reality they’re doing more. I believe a huge percentage of athletes in the Corps are also doing ROTC/contracting, so it’s laughable that somehow they’re a discredit to the Corps.
I can’t give you a hard and fast reason for the divide, but that is my opinion based on my observations. I often wonder how much the disbanding of some of the…um…societies has affected the overall demeanor of the Corps.
Corps leadership (students, not adults) actively tries to discourage athletic participation among Rooks. I know the commandant is aware and does not condone it (former NU student athlete himself).
The lack of actual cadets playing hockey for the Cadets probably hurts, but it isn’t like that’s a new set of circumstances. Norwich also has this bizarre (on campus) problem with acknowledging the difference between varsity and club sports. It’s common to hear kids say the club team is better than the varsity (we all know those games would be 10-0).
Finally, there was a severe crackdown on fan behavior which, I think, took a lot of the fun out of being a part of a raucous student section. I don’t condone profanity, etc but I believe a good student section should make it extremely uncomfortable to be a visitor. The student-athletes Friday night did a decent job of letting Castleton know they were in hostile territory.