ScoobyDoo
NPC
Re: New/Rented Movies: Bring Back Laserdiscs!
Frenzy didn't have a star cast. Not sure what you mean there. "To Catch a Thief" is a all star power and no power. If you want a good coutroom drama by a director on par with Hitch you go with Billy Wilder's "Witness for the Prosecution". If you swapped out "To Catch a Thief" with Psycho or Notorious then I probably wouldn't have felt compelled to comment. "To Catch a Thief" you watch for eye candy (Grace Kelly) and the beautiful scenery of the French countryside, and that's about it.
Jamaica Inn was based on a story by the same women who wrote the original stories for Rebecca and The Birds (interestingly enough). Jamaica Inn was terrible. Probably the worst of his films that I have watched. I agree that all the elements were there but it was horrible. I think if I read correctly the changes Laughton wanted and Hitch agreed to had a lot to do with the ruination of the film.
Well, we all have our likes and dislikes. "Star power" for instance -- that's just the way they fill the theatres -- in retrospect, who cares? And personally I think Frenzy is a terrible waste of a good cast and The Birds, while OK, is one of the most overrated movies ever made. (Also, if you don't think Paradine is a great courtroom drama, I'm not sure what color the sun is on your world). I made the "big four" list trying to be completely without controversy and also not too "challenging," in the way say the early Hitchs, particularly the silents, are. If it wasn't for that proviso I'd have included The 39 Steps, my personal favorite.
Frenzy didn't have a star cast. Not sure what you mean there. "To Catch a Thief" is a all star power and no power. If you want a good coutroom drama by a director on par with Hitch you go with Billy Wilder's "Witness for the Prosecution". If you swapped out "To Catch a Thief" with Psycho or Notorious then I probably wouldn't have felt compelled to comment. "To Catch a Thief" you watch for eye candy (Grace Kelly) and the beautiful scenery of the French countryside, and that's about it.
Jamaica Inn was based on a story by the same women who wrote the original stories for Rebecca and The Birds (interestingly enough). Jamaica Inn was terrible. Probably the worst of his films that I have watched. I agree that all the elements were there but it was horrible. I think if I read correctly the changes Laughton wanted and Hitch agreed to had a lot to do with the ruination of the film.
Last edited: