Re: New/Rented Movies: Bring Back Laserdiscs!
Anyway, my reasoning for why I didn't list those.
Well, we all have our likes and dislikes. "Star power" for instance -- that's just the way they fill the theatres -- in retrospect, who cares? And personally I think Frenzy is a terrible waste of a good cast and The Birds, while OK, is one of the most overrated movies ever made. (Also, if you don't think Paradine is a great courtroom drama, I'm not sure what color the sun is on your world

). I made the "big four" list trying to be completely without controversy and also not too "challenging," in the way say the early Hitchs, particularly the silents, are. If it wasn't for that proviso I'd have included The 39 Steps, my personal favorite.
Since you know your Hitch, what do you think of Jamaica Inn? For me it's one of the all-time great disappointments in film. It should have all the elements of a great Hitchcock, including a riveting backstory (one remade dozens of times in the 1890's through 1920's) and it has the classic "jam everyone together in a tight space and watch them interact" bottle episode formula that he really knew how to work.
Also in passing, if you know the Murder in the Red Barn story, another mainstay of late 19thC penny dreadfuls and yellowbacks, I always wish Hitch had, in his early period when he was doing those genre pieces, had explicitly done it (there are elements in lots of his films, but never a the real crux of the story). He should have loved it, to, with all the twisted sexual overtones and the infamy and social pressure that came from the crime, the trial, the execution, etc, etc...