Numbers are correct, but a couple of comments:
- look at who Hamilton played out of conference - Canton, Utica, St Mikes, Plymouth State, Oswego, Cortland, Potsdam. Not exactly a list of opponents to be feared. They don't even play Elmira who is just down the road from them. I would also guess that Hamilton's success against Middlebury might have something to do with the fact that their head coach was the Middlebury assistant coach for 3 years....
- Williams has a way harder out of conference schedule (but agree they should have done better) - Elmira, Castleton, Utica, Manhattanville, Adrian, St Olaf, Salve Regina, Sacred Heart - 2 top 10 teams.