Re: Movie Thread: New, Rental, Streaming
Marvel movies are their own beast...they have their template and it works for them. Each studio needs to do things their own way or it gets stale. (DC tried to make their universe that way when they did Green Lantern and it didnt fly) The X-Men movies arent the same as Marvel either and Age of Apocalypse is going to be uber dark but they work. The new Fantastic Four is nothing like Marvel films either and as I said Daredevil is made by Marvel Studios and it is no different than any Batman film imho. (which is why people love it)
Marvel Movies are successful because they know that characters are important not just hitting specific beats to make the fanboys happy. Can't say I would say Green Lantern tried to be like Marvel. It's more like MOS but with a small attempt at humor.
F4's look is visually dark but much of what is being shown is humor. It's also not produced by Marvel but by Fox.
Never been a fan of the Xmen movies until First Class. First was alright and second had it's moments but I wish I had never seen the rest.
And again, just being dark isn't being grimdark (as a negative). Daredevil is a dark setting but it's entire tone isn't set to that and it doesn't have it's positive moments.
As I have said quite a few times we are getting a glut of these movies the next 5 years or so (like 30 big budget cbms) and the only way it wont collapse under its own weight is to have different approaches. WB wants to have their world darker because they consider their heroes a pantheon of Gods fighting to protect the world. They want consequences that matter. Marvel wants it to be more lighthearted and make sure everyone knows everything is ok. Fox just runs with he themes of X-Men...etc.
The only way it doesn't collapse is that people continue to be alright with consuming movies as series and part of a greater whole. Considering the success that bubble doesn't look to be bursting anytime soon. At least not without several VERY large flops.
As for Batman what would you do? Campy wont work as has been shown. The only other type of Batman that has existed is the Neal Adams template (true detective style Batman) which I am not sure really will work in a movie. (though Affleck signed t write/direct a Batman solo and I feel he may go this way) While I agree that Frank Miller was terrible (I hate the Dark Knight Returns) the fact is Miller is why Batman is the money machine he is now. The Batgod is the #1 character in the world across almost any medium. (his comics outsell most others, his games are huge sellers, his cartoons are always running and his last movie franchise made $3 billion with zero crossovers) We may not like it but the vast, vast, vast, vast majority of people like that. The tragic kid who becomes a demigod who stands up to supernatural and universal forces he has no control of appeals to people on a primal level. The fact that despite being a member of the JLA he distrusts them all and would kill them if needed (like in Tower of Babel) appeals to the cynic in everyone. His rogues like the Joker are beloved not just cause of their look, but because they are true archetypes of evil...and are dark side versions of Batman himself. People today want his world dark...our mileage obviously does vary.
The god **** batman can die slowly in a fire. That said, he's about the only one who gets anything decent done with him for other media. Or even made recently. So saying that he's the number one draw ignores that there really isn't any competition for him.
You're missing out on one version that ran through the DCAU shows. Stern, unyielding vigilante but can't shy away from occasionally making a joke or showing compassion. Doesn't need to be a completely paranoid nutjob who's just out to get villains off the streets. He's a rich orphan with issues, a lot of issues, not one of the demigods he's willing to go up against.
<img src=http://38.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_mej1vuEz411rtdcj7o1_500.gif></img>
<img src=http://31.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_mej1vuEz411rtdcj7o2_500.gif></img>
<img src=http://33.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_mej1vuEz411rtdcj7o3_r1_500.gif></img>
As for this movie, while it starts dark it will end differently. It is called Dawn of Justice for a reason. It is always darkest just before the dawn...the universe isnt going to be like The Avengers where everyone is cracking one liners like Iron Man does but it isnt going to be like the Nolanverse either where everyone is miserable and the heroes are hard to define either. Whether it works or not chances are the movies will make booku bucks especially overseas and lets be honest. that is all that matters. Personally I like it but I understand those that dont.
Money is all that matters.