Re: Maine 2012 - Take 2. If This Ain't the Bottom...
Fact: Maine Hockey is now financially break even at best for this season. Season ticket sales have fallen off the table. It may still have made money up til two years ago, but no longer. UMaine suffers badly without the Hockey team ringing the cash register.
Opinion. You have no way of knowing what Maine's fiscal situation is. The latest data that is available is from 2010. At that point the profit was $700,000. I documented what seats are available this weekend for the Mercyhurst game, but they still make major money from ticket sales and have plenty of other revenue streams. It's been speculated for years that Maine's hockey revenue has dropped off the cliff, but they have remained constant even as attendance has fallen. Stop charging outrageous prices for tickets and people might come back. As I said, most people aren't going to shell out $50/game even to see our 42-1-2 team.
Fact: Maine Hockey still has full scholarship money. It has not been cut, even in horrible economic times.
This is true. Not sure why it is relevant, but to my knowledge no program in the university system has had to reduce the number or value of scholarships. I would expect the value of a scholarship has gone up as the tuition and other expenses have gone up.
Fact: At 4-9-2, Maine has little hope of recruiting great kids from anywhere...until something fundamentally changes. The lustre and elite stature are g-o-n-e gone.
Example: Gee, why did a freshman star goalie like Jon Gillies from South Portland end up at Providence College? The kid has played great so far this season, lifting a perennially mediocre team to 4th place currently in Hockey East.
More opinion. First of all, the record is 4-11-2. As to why Gillies went to Providence, let's look at this from both Maine's perspective and his perspective. From Maine's perspective, would you agree that devoting 4 scholarships to goaltending might be a slight misallocation of resources? If yes, then you would have to rescind the scholarship money from one of the keepers. Sullivan was the starter, backstopped the team to consecutive sweeps of BC and BU (for the first time ever, by anyone) and helped the team earn an NCAA bid. Matt Morris was an incoming freshman and highly regarded. Should Maine have told him to pound sand? More than likely you'd have lost Ouellette, who was on the outs with the coaching staff (and apparently some players) at the start of the season.
Now look at it from Gillies perspective. At Maine he would be behind Sullivan (and/or Ouellette) and fighting to be the #2 (or #3) with Morris. One of them more than likely would have been redshirted. There is a chance he could come here and have to wait two years or more to become a regular starter, if he ever did. Or he could walk into Providence, be the undisputed #1 from day one and have a full four years (or less if he goes pro) as the starter. Which way would you go? Tough decision there.