Re: Detroit Tigers, Volume 6: The Al Kaline edition
Leyland wasn't the "only" reason the Tigers lost... and the points made by J.D. are valid. BUT, his over-managing- especially with the pitching- was predictable and was countered effectly in 2006 by the Cardinals and especially in 2012 by SF. In many ways he was given a boy scout knife to a gun fight, but still chose to use the can opener instead.
One of the biggest pet peeves fans had was that he would "rest" too many star players during the season and lose winnable games with a soda pop lineup (with the ace on the mound.) He chose NOT to rest Cabrera and his injury pretty much gutted the Tigers offense.
I can't say that the Tigers will be better without him as all managers have their faults, but this team should have blown away the weak Central in the past and didn't. Now, teams like Cleveland and KC are much better- with better managers- and the window for making the playoffs is even slimmer than the 1-2 years that Hammer alluded to.
The Tigers offense was pretty much predicated on extra base hits. No speed and no creativity- and it was inflated against bad A.L. teams. The defense was okay (the Cabrera doubters saw his move the third as a mistake) but cracked at key times. The catching couldn't throw anyone out. This was a G.M. problem, not Leyland's, so he did what he could with what he had.
Leyland wasn't the "only" reason the Tigers lost... and the points made by J.D. are valid. BUT, his over-managing- especially with the pitching- was predictable and was countered effectly in 2006 by the Cardinals and especially in 2012 by SF. In many ways he was given a boy scout knife to a gun fight, but still chose to use the can opener instead.
One of the biggest pet peeves fans had was that he would "rest" too many star players during the season and lose winnable games with a soda pop lineup (with the ace on the mound.) He chose NOT to rest Cabrera and his injury pretty much gutted the Tigers offense.
I can't say that the Tigers will be better without him as all managers have their faults, but this team should have blown away the weak Central in the past and didn't. Now, teams like Cleveland and KC are much better- with better managers- and the window for making the playoffs is even slimmer than the 1-2 years that Hammer alluded to.
The Tigers offense was pretty much predicated on extra base hits. No speed and no creativity- and it was inflated against bad A.L. teams. The defense was okay (the Cabrera doubters saw his move the third as a mistake) but cracked at key times. The catching couldn't throw anyone out. This was a G.M. problem, not Leyland's, so he did what he could with what he had.