What's new
USCHO Fan Forum

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

  • The USCHO Fan Forum has migrated to a new plaform, xenForo. Most of the function of the forum should work in familiar ways. Please note that you can switch between light and dark modes by clicking on the gear icon in the upper right of the main menu bar. We are hoping that this new platform will prove to be faster and more reliable. Please feel free to explore its features.

Cops: No Snarky Nor Positive Title

Status
Not open for further replies.
Defend the Blue! Right?


They're just gojua continue to sandbag the investigation and hope this goes away.
 
The cops shouldn't try to swim out there unless they're trained rescue swimmers. They called for backup and the dude drowned. They have absolutely zero duty to swim out there.
 
The cops shouldn't try to swim out there unless they're trained rescue swimmers. They called for backup and the dude drowned. They have absolutely zero duty to swim out there.

I disagree. They and their sups should all be fired for being incompetent.
 
I disagree. They and their sups should all be fired for being incompetent.

For what? That they're not trained rescue swimmers? This isn't the same thing as charging into a school with a gunman. This is a fucking dumbass who put himself in extreme danger and no one else. The cops would have a very real chance of being drowned along with him if they tried to save him. I don't know if you've ever tried to help someone struggling in the water, but let me tell you, it's actually part of training that you may have to basically incapacitate the person if they start to become a danger to you both. Because being dragged under is an extremely real and likely possibility as the person fighting for their life does anything they can to stay above water.

Nah man. They aren't lifeguards. If someone climbs the side of a building, they have no obligation to scale the building and get the guy down.
 
For what? That they're not trained rescue swimmers? This isn't the same thing as charging into a school with a gunman. This is a fucking dumbass who put himself in extreme danger and no one else. The cops would have a very real chance of being drowned along with him if they tried to save him. I don't know if you've ever tried to help someone struggling in the water, but let me tell you, it's actually part of training that you may have to basically incapacitate the person if they start to become a danger to you both. Because being dragged under is an extremely real and likely possibility as the person fighting for their life does anything they can to stay above water.

Nah man. They aren't lifeguards. If someone climbs the side of a building, they have no obligation to scale the building and get the guy down.

I'm with DX on this one and I have more unreasonable hatred for all things law enforcement than any 10 of the rest of you. Certain rescues need to be done by people with specific training, and a water rescue is one of them. You don't know what your doing, especially when going after someone who will quite possibly not want you near them and you will probably need rescuing yourself. As a former lineman (as well as a former emergency responder) I knew more about a poletop rescue of someone suffering a medical emergency and being incapacitated 50 or 250 feet off the ground and could them down a lot quicker (and do it safely) than a lot of firefighters.
 
For what? That they're not trained rescue swimmers? This isn't the same thing as charging into a school with a gunman. This is a fucking dumbass who put himself in extreme danger and no one else. The cops would have a very real chance of being drowned along with him if they tried to save him. I don't know if you've ever tried to help someone struggling in the water, but let me tell you, it's actually part of training that you may have to basically incapacitate the person if they start to become a danger to you both. Because being dragged under is an extremely real and likely possibility as the person fighting for their life does anything they can to stay above water.

Nah man. They aren't lifeguards. If someone climbs the side of a building, they have no obligation to scale the building and get the guy down.

They. Are. Paid. To. Protect. People. (even and especially dumbasses) That includes protecting people from themselves.

I am sympathetic that it "might have put the cops in danger" to help, but that is their fucking job.

And watch the video, they aren't even pretending to be concerned they are sitting around like it is between periods of a Mite Game. They didn't really even attempt to stop him and they had plenty of time to do so. I put up more of an effort stopping my cat from killing bunnies outside. He doesn't even go into the water until 20 seconds and even sits on the concrete like 10 feet in front of the cop who just asks what he is doing and says he can't swim in the lake.

Your argument would be valid if they arrived on the scene and he was already in the water...they literally watched him run down and get prepared before going in. They obviously didn't think it was that big of a deal.

edit: we are likely not to agree so probably best to drop it.
 
Last edited:
They. Are. Paid. To. Protect. People. (even and especially dumbasses) That includes protecting people from themselves.

I am sympathetic that it "might have put the cops in danger" to help, but that is their fucking job.

And watch the video, they aren't even pretending to be concerned they are sitting around like it is between periods of a Mite Game. They didn't really even attempt to stop him and they had plenty of time to do so. I put up more of an effort stopping my cat from killing bunnies outside. He doesn't even go into the water until 20 seconds and even sits on the concrete like 10 feet in front of the cop who just asks what he is doing and says he can't swim in the lake.

Your argument would be valid if they arrived on the scene and he was already in the water...they literally watched him run down and get prepared before going in. They obviously didn't think it was that big of a deal.

edit: we are likely not to agree so probably best to drop it.

I didnt watch the video, but from the description of the lackadaisical cops, they may be negligent in the lack of pre-jump rescue.

But post-jump, if they are not water trained nor are lifeguards, the courts have agreed that they would most likely become drowning victims themselves.

(Your lack of concern after hearing that is noted.)

Their lack of concern pre- and post- jump (again, I havent seen the video, I'm mentally burnt out watching cops snuff the life from people in video clips on Twitter) is concerning and the cops shouldn't be badge holders anymore.




Short answer: I gotta agree with DX and WANDH, despite the lack of effort on the cops part.
 
And I'll echo that. I didn't watch the video for the same reasons. Cops suck. I'm very burnt out as well.

I am NOT saying they didn't massively fuck up before the guy jumped in the water. But once he was in the water, I don't think they have an obligation to put their lives in extreme risk. Again, this isn't a good guy vs a bad guy with a gun situation. It's more like disarming a bomb.

So handy is likely right about their actions before he entered and maybe even after. If they took their time to call for backup from the FD (which usually has someone trained in rescue swimming, but not always), then yeah, that's very problematic.
 
I have to admit that LivePD was a guilty pleasure of mine.
Same.


They see how many views cops whooping on Black/Browns/White Trash gets on Twitter and wants to cash in...
I never got that vibe from LivePD. They weren't charging in, throwing guys on hoods of cars like COPS.there seemed to be a more human element to it.

But yeah, holy wah did it put a giant fucking spotlight on the classist differences. But that might have also been because of the departments shown. Rural Louisiana, Florida, Georgia, and Arizona is gonna be different on TV from Naperville IL, Newton MA, Bloomfield Hills MI, etc.
 
I have to admit that while I am pessimistic about the future for a lot of reasons, we have seen some improvement in what happens when cops shoot people. A Grand Rapids (MI) cop has been arrested (and publicly identified) for shooting and killing a black motorist. 10 years ago we probably would have had only the cops version of what happened, and he would not have been charged. 5 years ago we'd all see cell phone footage but it would still have been unlikely the cop would be charged. Instead we are now beginning to see these idiots (at best) charged for their gross negligence (again, at best it is negligent) and even seeing quite a few convicted. When enough go to prison, we will see a change.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top