Sean Pickett
2009 NCAA Champions
Re: BU 2017 Season Thread II: Terriers rising
In my opinion Delia got the Goaltender award because of the "everyone gets a participation medal" mentality. I truly think that the league wants to spread around the honors as much as possible and this was one of the few honors that could go to a Merrimack player this year.
Sean
I haven't seen any such stats online, but the shots sheets for each period do show where every shot was taken from on the ice. Using those you could determine how many shots and goals were from in close, the sides, the blue line, outside the blue line, etc. and create the advanced stats you are referring to.I agree that Delia shouldn't win. should be petersen or oettinger but GAA has more to do with the team in front of you. at the same time even save percentage can be deceiving because what if you are facing higher quality chances because you have a weaker team in front of you (i am sure there are advanced stats for that somewhere).
Huska did meet the minutes played threshold (he played almost 35 minutes more than Delia). Also, do you consider the league scoring leader title also relatively meaningless?Sure, you're right about the use of stats but if you then incorporate the "eye test" that still would likely leave you with the same two standout candidates being argued here in Oettinger and Petersen. I believe Huska isn't considered because of minutes played, while Delia clearly did meet the minutes played threshold. It's a relatively meaningless award and Delia certainly had a great season and performed remarkably against BU in the two we played.
There are a few other stats that I think are important, including wins, shutouts and winning percentage, but as they are even more impacted by team play they are harder to quantify when comparing goalies. That said I would vote for Oettinger on the first team and Petersen on the second team, but I'm sure part of that is my bias.Given all the additional info, I feel confident that Petersen will get first team and Oettinger will get second team.
In my opinion Delia got the Goaltender award because of the "everyone gets a participation medal" mentality. I truly think that the league wants to spread around the honors as much as possible and this was one of the few honors that could go to a Merrimack player this year.
Sean