What's new
USCHO Fan Forum

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

  • The USCHO Fan Forum has migrated to a new plaform, xenForo. Most of the function of the forum should work in familiar ways. Please note that you can switch between light and dark modes by clicking on the gear icon in the upper right of the main menu bar. We are hoping that this new platform will prove to be faster and more reliable. Please feel free to explore its features.

2017 Atlantic Hurricane Season: Non-Minnesotans arguing about the weather...

Re: 2017 Atlantic Hurricane Season: Non-Minnesotans arguing about the weather...

All those people that were relocated from New Orleans to Houston after Katrina, get to relive this sh*t all over again.

It's sad but if they had done a little reading they would have known that Houston had zero city planning for anything like this. From the reporting this morning they paved over flood plains without even batting an eyelash.
 
Re: 2017 Atlantic Hurricane Season: Non-Minnesotans arguing about the weather...

It's sad but if they had done a little reading they would have known that Houston had zero city planning for anything like this. From the reporting this morning they paved over flood plains without even batting an eyelash.
I'm not sure that if you were to look into the emergency management plans of any U.S. city you're going to find a chapter entitled, "What to do when you get 50 inches of rain."
 
Re: 2017 Atlantic Hurricane Season: Non-Minnesotans arguing about the weather...

I'm not sure that if you were to look into the emergency management plans of any U.S. city you're going to find a chapter entitled, "What to do when you get 50 inches of rain."

As I understand it this has happened before. However, this time it's 12' higher. It's just another example of how we never learn.
 
Re: 2017 Atlantic Hurricane Season: Non-Minnesotans arguing about the weather...

I'm not sure that if you were to look into the emergency management plans of any U.S. city you're going to find a chapter entitled, "What to do when you get 50 inches of rain."

You took the words right out of my mouth. This has never happened before in the US since we started detailing weather records. I heard this morning that experts have estimated this storm has dropped over 11 trillion gallons of water and it's not over yet.

Scooby, there aren't many places in the US that can handle four feet of rain in under a week. Probably none.

Put the amount of rain in perspective, to date in 2017, MSP has received 27" of rain. They received that in the first 24-48 hours.

What could they possibly have learned. You throw out "but this time it's 12' higher" like it's inconsequential. How the hell do you learn from that?

Did you mean 12" more rain? Even then, how do you fix that in a city like Houston. Even $100 billion to put that kind of infrastructure in would be just scratching the surface. We're probably talking about something closer to a $1 trillion to fix a city of that size's infrastructure to handle a storm like this.
 
Last edited:
Re: 2017 Atlantic Hurricane Season: Non-Minnesotans arguing about the weather...

I'm not sure that if you were to look into the emergency management plans of any U.S. city you're going to find a chapter entitled, "What to do when you get 50 inches of rain."

Still, the very definition of risk mitigation is there is a chapter entitled "What you can do when the unimaginably awful happens." For example, in the USG we have continuity of operations plans and the last chapter is literally "Catastrophe Mitigation," where the event is left undefined but it stands for "even worse" than the specified scenarios. Considering one of the specified scenarios is nuclear war... Anyway, the Catastrophe Mitigation is a set of protocols that depend on what's left: do you have infrastructure, do you have comms, do you have a command structure, etc. At each stage there are steps you take to try to prevent even more massive damage. This is actually one of the key responsibilities of government.
 
Re: 2017 Atlantic Hurricane Season: Non-Minnesotans arguing about the weather...

Still, the very definition of risk mitigation is there is a chapter entitled "What you can do when the unimaginably awful happens." For example, in the USG we have continuity of operations plans and the last chapter is literally "Catastrophe Mitigation," where the event is left undefined but it stands for "even worse" than the specified scenarios. Considering one of the specified scenarios is nuclear war... Anyway, the Catastrophe Mitigation is a set of protocols that depend on what's left: do you have infrastructure, do you have comms, do you have a command structure, etc. At each stage there are steps you take to try to prevent even more massive damage. This is actually one of the key responsibilities of government.

^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

And part of that is stop building in flood plains. And below sea level.
 
Re: 2017 Atlantic Hurricane Season: Non-Minnesotans arguing about the weather...

I'm glad everything is so simple and black and white in ScoobyWorld. Because in the real world, things are more complicated.

Houston is enormous because of the number of jobs there driven by one of the nation's largest oil and gas ports. People go where the jobs are. Planning for 1,000-year events is simply an impossibility in a society with limited resources.

How would you plan to relocate the six million people there? How do possibly plan around all 1,000-year events for an area?
 
Re: 2017 Atlantic Hurricane Season: Non-Minnesotans arguing about the weather...

I'm glad everything is so simple and black and white in ScoobyWorld. Because in the real world, things are more complicated.

Houston is enormous because of the number of jobs there driven by one of the nation's largest oil and gas ports. People go where the jobs are. Planning for 1,000-year events is simply an impossibility in a society with limited resources.

How would you plan to relocate the six million people there? How do possibly plan around all 1,000-year events for an area?

You can't. BUT. You can do more. And they don't do more, why? Cause Republicans that's why.

From my article I posted.

Brody's hope is that there'll be greater leadership from the local and federal government to "genuinely start dealing with this flood issue."

"It's not a matter of will we get this again in some form? We absolutely will," Brody said. "The question is what is the cost of doing nothing or not doing enough going forward?"

Brody warned, "And every year we don't start thinking systematically about protection and mitigation for a lot of different areas, the price of tagging the next storm continues to go up."
 
Last edited:
I'm glad everything is so simple and black and white in ScoobyWorld. Because in the real world, things are more complicated.

Houston is enormous because of the number of jobs there driven by one of the nation's largest oil and gas ports. People go where the jobs are. Planning for 1,000-year events is simply an impossibility in a society with limited resources.

How would you plan to relocate the six million people there? How do possibly plan around all 1,000-year events for an area?

Send them back to New Orleans?? (just kidding)
 
Re: 2017 Atlantic Hurricane Season: Non-Minnesotans arguing about the weather...

I get where Scooby is coming from, but he could be a lot less of a dick about it. Especially while the disaster is, you know, still ongoing and getting worse.
 
Re: 2017 Atlantic Hurricane Season: Non-Minnesotans arguing about the weather...

I hope that hockeyplayer1015 is OK. He hasn't posted since early yesterday afternoon.
 
I'm glad everything is so simple and black and white in ScoobyWorld. Because in the real world, things are more complicated.

Houston is enormous because of the number of jobs there driven by one of the nation's largest oil and gas ports. People go where the jobs are. Planning for 1,000-year events is simply an impossibility in a society with limited resources.

How would you plan to relocate the six million people there? How do possibly plan around all 1,000-year events for an area?

Well, it might help to start planning for the next one, because global warming will turn 1000 year events into 100 year events.
 
Well, it might help to start planning for the next one, because global warming will turn 1000 year events into 100 year events.

Will still be cheaper to rebuild one city every 100 years than to retrofit them all to make waterproof
 
Back
Top