This has been mentioned a lot. Technically, they could try to bring in an affiliate team. But you're right, the LL teams do not want to leave the ECAC, so there's no incentive for them to look to create a LL D1 conference. Only if they are forced to because someone already in the LL went D1 hockey, but we know Hobart is not doing that.And a sixth team would get the Liberty League an autobid to the D1 tournament. I know there's probably not interest in breaking up the ECAC but...
First, what Hobart is doing is amazing, historical, and they deserve all the accolades. I was here for the Middlebury run, so this ranks right up there. As Hobart's #1 fan on this board, I appreciate your insight and positivity when the banter goes sideways. I speculate the SUNYAC only invited Hobart because they heard Statesmen was your nickname and said, "they must be one of us..."Great point Russell. HWS and Skidmore are in the Liberty league which is a great D3 league for all sports. But RPI, RIT, Clarkson and SLU and Union all are D1 hockey, so what would be an awesome D3 hockey league has no remaining critical mass for the remaining D3 teams So HWS hockey teams were looking for a new league and the SUNYAC is geographically desirable and has a great hockey tradition, so we were happy to accept the invitation.. Hobart has absolutely no interest in going D! for hockey, we did that in lacrosse and we are barely over .500 since moving up because we have to compete with other very strong D1 programs in the A10. Frankly, I wish we never moved up to D1 , because programs like Johns Hopkins and Syracuse have real NIL programs and very significant institutional support. I remember the old days when Cortland lacrosse was a big rival in the D3 days and we would beat them in some great Championship match ups in lacrosse and the Cortland fans said Hobart must be paying players with excessive "merit" scholarships . Funny, now the SUNTAC is saying the hockey program is doing the same thing,
This was an NCAA D3 violation and private schools fell afoul of it as well (can you say Neumann?). It had nothing to do with NY public schools alone.A recent example would be finding an uneven number of international financial scholarships given to hockey players at OZ (and maybe Platty, don't remember).
The WIAC schools left. It was more of a power play move than anything else, as most people saw it. The WIAC schools didn't want to be "beholden" to the other NCHA institutions, and felt that if they left, the NCHA schools would be forced to join them, but under the WIAC label (which might have had more restrictions in what you could do financially, so that might have been part of it). So, it wasn't a public/private thing but rather a WIAC vs. NCHA thing. The WIAC schools weren't going to have an issue if the private schools wanted to join their league as affiliate members. The private schools saw what was happening, and told the WIAC to pound sand, leaving the WIAC without an auto bid. While the NCHA schools found other schools to join and keep their AQ.Didn’t this whole ‘private/public’ topic go the complete opposite direction about 10-15 years ago (2013???) involving the Wisconsin schools? I seem to recall the NCHA consisted of the Wisconsin state schools and a few privates, and that conference split along private/public lines which I believe was due to underlying financial concerns, ultimately forming the WIAC. I cannot remember who “took their puck and went home” as a result… the privates or the publics, but I am fairly certain that the main cause of the split was financial (resource) disparity.
It wasn’t finances it was just the WIAC commissioner being a power hungry idiotDidn’t this whole ‘private/public’ topic go the complete opposite direction about 10-15 years ago (2013???) involving the Wisconsin schools? I seem to recall the NCHA consisted of the Wisconsin state schools and a few privates, and that conference split along private/public lines which I believe was due to underlying financial concerns, ultimately forming the WIAC. I cannot remember who “took their puck and went home” as a result… the privates or the publics, but I am fairly certain that the main cause of the split was financial (resource) disparity.
Oh and tCSS is in the MIAC now, so that is probably a better geographic fit for them?Long term, the WIAC/NCHA split has worked out pretty well for everyone involved. The UW schools all have a 1 in 5 chance at an AQ every year (sorryNorthlandBeloit) and the new NCHA has become arguably the best top to bottom conference in D3.