Re: Your one do-over.
Something to keep the creative juices flowing here everybody. Pick that one game, from the entire history of games you've watched that if you could play it over again because your team lost on a flukey goal or a back call perhaps. A loss to a big rival, or something from tournement time perhaps??
Two choices for NU:
1994 vs. Lake Superior in the NCAA tournament
2002 Beanpot final vs. BU
I lean towards the latter, as I just don't think the 1994 team was strong enough in goal to win it all (though they could score with anyone on their day). The Beanpot was really painful, that was Fahey's senior season and he had scored the 3-2 goal (wound up logging something like 45 minutes of ice time in that game).
Maybe the 1994 Beanpot, too... with Harvard upsetting BU, NU would have had a great shot at winning if we had only been able to win the OT game vs. BC.
One really obvious choice for ND:
2008 national title game. Change the result, and we win the title. Duh. I wonder how that game might have changed if the disputed goal had been ruled good, considering how well ND started the period.
Two second choices for ND, too:
2007 regional final vs. Michigan State, which maybe could be done by making the Alabama-Huntsville game end in regulation.
2009 regional game vs. Bemidji
The second choices are more interesting here. I lean towards the former, as I think ND might very well have won the national title if they'd made it through the MSU game. By comparison, as much as I like the 2009 team, they would have had some really tough tests to even get to the title game, let alone win it.