critsports
Registered User
Re: Yale Hockey 2010-2011 thread
I am sure he will.......my only thought is "standard practice" aside.......if the other coach makes the effort to walk out, I say return the gesture of sportsmanship. I think Allain's lack of doing so speaks volume's about his demeanor and thought process. I can easily understand as a Ylae fan how you would be delighted with what he has done for the program. He has taken it from an also ran to a team of national prominence.
We must have been sitting next to each other as it happened right in front of us as well. I think the only way we can know for certain is to watch the tape and I will talk to some friends who normally get the opportunity to do that. If I learn anything I'll share it. I agree Baker was vulnerable, had his head down (always a bad thing) and I did talk to one SLU fan/parent who agreed with your opinion. I also talked with several others who were watching from up high (which often gives a wider perspective than down low where we were) and they felt it was a "major" type penalty and not just a minor infraction. They described it as a leg being stuck out by the Ylae player and the resultant knee on knee hit. I haven't heard how Baker is but before he left the rink for the hospital they were pretty sure it was a fractured fibula.
Agreed and that is the point, and to try and do so without being dirty which unfortunately because of the poor officiating.....both teams crossed that line repeatedly. The goal for SLU was to try and not necessarily intimidate but take Ylae off it's game, but to their credit that incredible passing and attacking skill still dominated. I posted on our link yesterday that in order for us to "have any chance of winning" we had to stay out of the box. I also said the second key to winning was to stay out of the box.
I too am hoping for a great game but the disparity of records is there for a reason. We are also going to be depleted on defense one and perhaps two players which is going to be difficult to overcome. We have to hope for another big night from Weninger...a few lucky bounces, and some things to go our way which last night almost none of them did. Lost in the nastiness was the fact (scoreboard aside) I really felt the play was much more "even" last night than on Friday where Ylae dominated territorially. We had lot's of shots and chances but the difference was your guys buried theirs. Regardless of outcome this SLU team has obtained a lot of experience and while we lose some key contributors like Bogosian the fact is we are playing with many, many freshman who will benefit from this experience.
I appreciate you past support, if last night’s game, and my opinion are going to change your mind about Yale, so be it.
So many of us have been ardent supporters of our ECAC brethren who have done well, your opinion has nothing to do with my loss of respect for the current Ylae offering…….it was all about the “yapping, complaining, diving, griping, and posturing”. We support talented teams from our league because we are proud of the league, our teams, the league’s rich history and our desire despite admittedly the toughest academic standards in hockey and the limitations that imposes, to return a team to the Frozen Four and possibly win a Championship
I agree that the officiating was terrible and am hoarse from screaming at Whittemore, my comment about SLU getting chippy after Yale took the quick 4-1 lead is valid IMO, the head high checks and runs were so obvious that an SLU player hurt himself after missing an attempt to board a Yalie. I hope that one tough game will not spoil a nice relationship that Yale fans and yourself have had, I will not resort to name calling (I reserve that for particular NoDak fans), but please do not disparage my knowledge of hockey or what I feel took place last night, we can all have our opinions. The worst part about the game last night was that three kids were seriously hurt and for that I blame the refs.
Agreed and questioning knowledge is not normally in my nature. I take more exception to the one- sidedness of your view. Others posting have agreed and presented more balanced views and have concurred with some of the points I made.
I think the reason Yale get's alot of calls is their small stature, I agree they do a good job of "selling" calls, but there were a few dives on SLU's end as well. The officials were so terrible that it really didn't matter after a while, because there was no rhyme or reason for some of the calls. I do remember one non call against Yale that got fixed about 30 seconds later with a call for something minor, there was no figuring them out last night. I think we can agree that we do not respect each other’s teams anymore, but as fans I think we are entitled to our opinions of what we saw, and can continue to have civil relationships.
Agreed…..but selling doesn’t mean you have to constantly yip and complain.
He acts that way to Yale fans, so I have no excuse, although I will say I thought he should have the right to criticize those officials last night.
Certainly both coaches have the right to criticize and I have seen Coach Marsh lose his cool on more than one occasion including in this series.
As for Coach Allain, I am sure he could be tough to take from the outside, but as a Yale fan it is difficult to not like what he has done to the program.
And it is standard practice in a playoff series that coaches (and players) do not shake hands until after the deciding game of the series. I am sure win or lose tonight Coach Allain will walk to center ice and and shake hands with Coach Marsh.
I am sure he will.......my only thought is "standard practice" aside.......if the other coach makes the effort to walk out, I say return the gesture of sportsmanship. I think Allain's lack of doing so speaks volume's about his demeanor and thought process. I can easily understand as a Ylae fan how you would be delighted with what he has done for the program. He has taken it from an also ran to a team of national prominence.
I think we can all agree that the officiating was awful and the Yale players need to stop throwing there arms up in frustration after every play, but exactly what should have been the call on Ziegler? The play was directly in front of me and it wasnt a penalty. The SLU player was skating with his head down being chased from behind and saw the hit coming at the very last second second and tried to move out of the way and it made things look very awkward. I felt awful for the player as he was in alot pain, but it wasnt a penalty.
We must have been sitting next to each other as it happened right in front of us as well. I think the only way we can know for certain is to watch the tape and I will talk to some friends who normally get the opportunity to do that. If I learn anything I'll share it. I agree Baker was vulnerable, had his head down (always a bad thing) and I did talk to one SLU fan/parent who agreed with your opinion. I also talked with several others who were watching from up high (which often gives a wider perspective than down low where we were) and they felt it was a "major" type penalty and not just a minor infraction. They described it as a leg being stuck out by the Ylae player and the resultant knee on knee hit. I haven't heard how Baker is but before he left the rink for the hospital they were pretty sure it was a fractured fibula.
Crit, sorry you won't be cheering for us, but I think we can survive that. Having watched Yale all year, I agree with some of your comments, and it was clear to me that SLU came out trying to send a message and intimidate. To do so, there was loads of extra hits many of which including leading with high elboys, grabbing, and even extra pucnhes to the head during scrums. This was successful and resulted in Yale players complaining to the refs. When this had no effects and SLU continued, then Yale complained a little more, and when nothing changed they got ****ed off. As a result a Yale team that usually doesn't focus on finishing off hard checks, or giving that extra shot when available, decided that they were going to do that and then do it again, and then do it some more.
I hate to see anyone get hurt, an no one should be happy with that, but if you are going to set the kind of tone SLU did, then you better not take for granted that Yale will just roll over and let you do what you want, and to the end, you better keep your head up.
By the way, it's a playoff series, we shake hands at the end. Should be a great game tonight.
Agreed and that is the point, and to try and do so without being dirty which unfortunately because of the poor officiating.....both teams crossed that line repeatedly. The goal for SLU was to try and not necessarily intimidate but take Ylae off it's game, but to their credit that incredible passing and attacking skill still dominated. I posted on our link yesterday that in order for us to "have any chance of winning" we had to stay out of the box. I also said the second key to winning was to stay out of the box.
I too am hoping for a great game but the disparity of records is there for a reason. We are also going to be depleted on defense one and perhaps two players which is going to be difficult to overcome. We have to hope for another big night from Weninger...a few lucky bounces, and some things to go our way which last night almost none of them did. Lost in the nastiness was the fact (scoreboard aside) I really felt the play was much more "even" last night than on Friday where Ylae dominated territorially. We had lot's of shots and chances but the difference was your guys buried theirs. Regardless of outcome this SLU team has obtained a lot of experience and while we lose some key contributors like Bogosian the fact is we are playing with many, many freshman who will benefit from this experience.