That's not really true. The only guy missing during Nations League was Adams.
At any rate, starting the qualifying campaign strong absolutely should be expected. You have over 2 years to make it happen. Showing up unprepared is a failure. Not necessarily an insurmountable failure, but a failure none the less.
I have seen these guys play and have a baseline for what they can do. I'm not interested in using half the qualifying schedule to learn what they or Berhalter are about. I'm interested in using it to...you know...qualify for the fucking World Cup.
They are still in position, even if it is more tenuous than it should be. 2nd half today was an enormous rescue. Absolutely must carry that 2nd half into the October window.
You’re glossing over a metric fuckton of factors.
a) Youth. Most of these players are still U23s and this is their first Qualifying campaign. CONCACAF has a steep learning curve and shows no mercy and cares not about who you play for.
b) Travel. This is the first time the majority of these players have had to deal with this kind of schedule. Fly in from Europe, have maybe two days to get ready before getting on a plane again to go to Central America, play, fly back, three days later play again, immediately travel again to play again. Jet lag is a mother fucker.
c) Conditions. These guys don’t play in 95%+ humidity on a field that looks worse than $2 pitch and putt course all the time.
People need to understand, just because they play in Europe on big teams does not mean they will be successful with the National Team in CONCACAF. John Brooks is a starting CB in the Bundesliga and was the worst player this window, with a guy from Barcelona on his heels. The guy from Juventus had to be sent home.
You know what 11 players scored four goals? 6 MLSers, a guy who plays in Austria, a guy who plays in Belgium, a guy who plays in Turkey, a guy in the Championship, and 1 solitary Bundesliga player.