jmh
win or lose, we booze
Re: World Soccer XXV - the run up to the World Cup
Was anyone else confused to see Chandler go in on the left for Beasley, rather than Johnson moving over to the left and Chandler coming in on the right? I know Johnson plays on either side for Hoffenheim and has played more on the right in the second half of the season, but Chandler has, as far as I can tell, never played on the left.
As far as injuries or suspensions go, the guy I'm most concerned about is Altidore. I think we have reasonable depth in most places but I don't know that any of the other forward options have the kind of physical presence that we might need to relieve pressure if our defense is overwhelmed.
Sure, but if you want to be rational about it, you can't just say "Beckerman is better than Edu because they play similar roles and RSL is a better team than Philly". RSL has a better roster overall, and they're a better team as a result. And if by saying "Beckerman can replace Bradley or Jones in the lineup in case of injury or suspension" what you mean is that Beckerman can play the forward point of a diamond 4-4-2 midfield like we saw yesterday, it's a moot point because neither Edu nor Beckerman would be used in that case. So, I am rationally thinking about how they fit, despite how you want to characterize what I'm saying. What I'm saying, rationally, is that neither of them is good enough to play an attacking role at the World Cup, so it doesn't matter that Beckerman plays a more attacking role for RSL, and Edu is better defensively.Well, he's good holding midfielder. He's one of the best in MLS and Edu is not. Philly hasn't been lighting it up with Edu this season and yet there's RSL near the top. Neither one of them is going to start and Beckerman can replace Bradley or Jones in the lineup in case of injury or suspension. Edu can't.
You can't rationally think about how players fit in a formation and a team. All you think is "Beckerman sucks!" without giving any reason why.
Was anyone else confused to see Chandler go in on the left for Beasley, rather than Johnson moving over to the left and Chandler coming in on the right? I know Johnson plays on either side for Hoffenheim and has played more on the right in the second half of the season, but Chandler has, as far as I can tell, never played on the left.
As far as injuries or suspensions go, the guy I'm most concerned about is Altidore. I think we have reasonable depth in most places but I don't know that any of the other forward options have the kind of physical presence that we might need to relieve pressure if our defense is overwhelmed.