There's a better chance you see Hughes than Sheehy, based on what I've gathered. It could certainly happen (both), but there really seems to be some conflicting rumors on UW's interest in Sheehy.
Sheehy should be a priority, IMO, but I'm not on the staff. I don't blame UW one bit for waiting until he had more USHL experience to see how he stacked up in that setting, but the kid continues to rack up points. I've talked to the Waterloo coaches and they really like him. Sheehy was 14 steps ahead of everyone else during the Elite League this season, and it was a great move by him to go to the USHL. It would have done him no good to dominate game in, game out all winter. Challenging himself in the USHL was the right move and he's still succeeding.
I've seen him play probably 15 times in the past 12 months and he keeps getting better and better. I have no doubt at this point he can step in next season and at least be a serviceable player in the Big Ten. It's those next three years where I think he'll really take off as a college player. He's not an NHL consideration, so you've got a four year guy who is going to score and put up points in college. Given UW's situation, the fact that he's not already locked up is puzzling to me.
Obviously none of us are privy to Wisconsin's recruiting board, so maybe there are a few options we don't know about. But if they don't go after Sheehy, I think that would be a mistake.