He never said they were not one of the top teams in the country. Once again, the deflection from his question. Not to mention, all you need to do is look at the past 10 years (don't worry about 25) and compare programs like SNC or Stevens Point or Norwich to Utica. Heck, compare Geneseo -- at least they made it to the semifinal four times in that span. Utica has won just one freaking NCAA playoff game. One!
Fishman was asked what makes Utica a perennial contender. He never answered.
Hint: Like you said, they are not.
I think this whole “perennial national contender” argument is crazy. First off, it is completely arbitrary, and there is nothing that distinguishes a “perennial national contender” other than your agenda against Utica. It could very well be a team that is consistently ranked top 10 year after year. You are comparing a 20 year old program to legendary D3 programs. Let me know when you want to get off your high horse, Russell.