Re: USCHO Music Thread 2: Rock On, Amigo.
Was this on the greatest hits collection?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zk4AaPXZgi0
I have the first two albums they did after McDonald joined the band, and they're not bad. I don't really mind his singing at all on these, and he did rejuvenate the band at a time when they badly needed it. Even brought a little bit of an R&B/funky groove to some of their stuff. C'mon, Takin' it to the Strrets is just a classic. What a bass line.
But the longer he was in the band, and the more he came to dominate them, the worse they got. They cleaned up and mellowed out. I mean, look at Patrick Simmons in the middle of this cover photo from 1980. Total mainstream corporate pop music scene.
http://cps-static.rovicorp.com/3/JPG_500/MI0003/591/MI0003591325.jpg?partner=allrovi.com
And look at him now in that video. Ditched all the fancy clothes and thousand dollar hair stylists, and went back to being himself.
Lame, MOR pop stuff. Thank god he left, and they got Tom Johnston to come back. Their new original stuff may be a bit derivative of their older sound, but the live performances with him are great.
Bob Seger did the same thing, rowdy raucus rock and roll cleaned up and polished of all the rough edges. Money and success are not very complementary to the creative process.