What's new
By:
USCHO Fan Forum

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

  • The USCHO Fan Forum has migrated to a new plaform, xenForo. Most of the function of the forum should work in familiar ways. Please note that you can switch between light and dark modes by clicking on the gear icon in the upper right of the main menu bar. We are hoping that this new platform will prove to be faster and more reliable. Please feel free to explore its features.

SCOTUS 15: Help Us, Ruth Bader Ginsburg! You're Our Only Hope!

Status
Not open for further replies.
unofan said:
My quick, quick, quick read:
Everyone in the country has to comply with legitimate Congressional subpoenas, but there's really no record to determine whether the interests of the congress were properly balanced with the executive's. So remand to get a better record.
Click to expand...

And then he added some 4-part test I'm reading? And that has to be complied with prior to remand? That seems to be the mechanism to run out the clock before the election.
 
tl;dr:

7-2 - court says presidents are not immune from state or congressional investigations and subpoenas. But they can object to and raise defenses during such investigations. So lower courts and state courts, have these back.

Edit: And to be fair to Alito and Thomas, it was 9-0 in stating that Presidents are not kings and are not absolutely immune from any and all investigations. Thomas and Alito just would find that these specific cases are, to borrow a phrase, Presidential Harassment.
 
Last edited:
aparch said:
More interesting to me was SCOTUS calling out Congress, and the US Government in general, in their ruling over the Oklahoma case. They basically defended the Native American tribe and told Congress that of they don't want to uphold their promise of a reservation in perpetuity to the tribe, to sh** or get off the pot. Instead of Congress dancing around by changing the reservation size and powers the tribe has, make it clear what they want.
Click to expand...

I've been talking to a USG lawyer about this and he says the contracts doctrine of conservatives makes interesting exceptions and tweaks for non-US parties, and that tribes are so considered, at least prior to 14A, but Gorsuch came along in Sharp and said "f-ck that." He recused in Sharp which was then 4-4 so they brought it back with McGirt and he dropped the hammer. My friend thinks this is a BFD because prior to this the rule of thumb was the injuns always lose because if they win seriously bad stuff starts happening to rich people, but Gorsuch has put his fellow cons on notice that he really does not care, a contract's a contract.

Basically all the other rulings which clearly f-cked over the feathers when the USG decided to unilaterally abrogate treaties for "legal" rationales which amounted to force majeur are now in jeopardy.

Huh. Who woulda thunk it? Bet the Federalist Society is having a freak out.
 
I understand the rulings on the tax returns. Yes I'd like to see Chump's tax returns released immediately and then him hauled out of the WH in leg irons. However the ruling seems to be fair even if it does delay viewing the info until after the election.
 
Rover said:
I understand the rulings on the tax returns. Yes I'd like to see Chump's tax returns released immediately and then him hauled out of the WH in leg irons. However the ruling seems to be fair even if it does delay viewing the info until after the election.
Click to expand...

Hopefully it gets leaked from NY.
 
Today's Supreme Court rulings on Donald Trump's hidden financial materials are a mixed bag for all involved. On the one hand, the justices rejected the woeful arguments presented by the president's attorneys, but on the other, the high court also sent the matters back to lower courts for a lengthy review.

Or put another way, Trump lost on principle, but prevailed on politics: the practical effects of the rulings will mean the president's secret documents, including his tax returns, will remain under wraps until well after Election Day 2020.
Click to expand...

So, we pretty much get nothing out of today's rulings.

https://www.msnbc.com/rachel-maddow...v9-9m1URxVCr2_dkcCw6QlgDrYSqgT7l7jDPqF7bO0vPg

As a consolation prize he better be in jail by sometime next year or we for sure know there is no justice in America.
 
Ted Cruz says, "The Supreme Court just gave away half of Oklahoma, literally. Manhattan is next."

That's a weird say of saying that treaties actually mean something.
 
Spartanforlife4 said:
Ted Cruz says, "The Supreme Court just gave away half of Oklahoma, literally. Manhattan is next."

That's a weird say of saying that treaties actually mean something.
Click to expand...

Also shows that Ted Cruz doesn't know what the fu** he's talking about.


All this means is that any laws broken on tribal land, by a native American, must be handled either by Tribal court for misdemeanors or by the Federal Government for more serious crimes. The State Courts of Oklahoma are not recognized by the tribes.

From the brief articles I have read, this *could* affect a wide range of cases where native Americans are serving time in state prison. But as was pointed out, the Federal Government is much more strict in their sentencing which could lead to stiffer jail time if anyone tries to appeal their current sentence.



With that said, I fully expect Unofan or others with their ear much closer to the ground on this to correct me. :)
 
ScoobyDoo said:
So, we pretty much get nothing out of today's rulings.

https://www.msnbc.com/rachel-maddow...v9-9m1URxVCr2_dkcCw6QlgDrYSqgT7l7jDPqF7bO0vPg

As a consolation prize he better be in jail by sometime next year or we for sure know there is no justice in America.
Click to expand...

This probably saves the Democrats from themselves. Having a bunch of hearings over his tax returns while people continue to die from the virus and find themselves out of work won't look good.

Trump isn't going to lose because someone finds out he isn't as rich as he says or took out some shady loans. You either know he's a con man or nothing will change your mind. He is going to lose because he has botched a pandemic and helped destroy the economy.
 
SCOTUS trying to ensure Florida stays with the GOP, allows its poll tax on convicted felons to go forward while litigation is still pending.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top